With 'Nexit' Nixed, Expect A Pro-EU Dutch Government

by: Neil Dwane


The defeat of Geert Wilders and the PVV leads us to believe another coalition of pro-EU parties will be formed.

As a result, the Netherlands should not be the next Brexit-style domino to fall in Europe.

With the Dutch economy in good shape, we do not expect the new government to implement any dramatic changes to its economic policies.

The Netherlands benefits from global free trade and a weak euro, to the extent that its investment prospects are less like its European neighbours and more like its global counterparts.

The Netherlands is a strong EU member with attractive credit fundamentals and a triple-A rating; the markets’ attention will now turn to elections in France, Germany and possibly Italy.

In the Netherlands, coalitions are critical

On 15 March, millions of Dutch voters went to the polls to elect 150 members of the Tweede Kamer (House of Representatives), which will use proportional representation to divide its 150 seats according to the number of votes won by each political party represented in the election.

Unlike in other countries, in the Netherlands it is virtually unthinkable to see one political party win a majority vote and lead the country; instead, governments run by coalitions are the norm because it takes 75 seats to form a government, and winning that many seats is extremely difficult. At the same time, forming a coalition is also very challenging: In 2010, coalition negotiations lasted 127 days - a relatively quick turnaround compared to 1977's negotiations, which took a record 207 days.

These are some of the reasons why the last party that held an outright majority in the Netherlands was the Liberal Union party in the early 20th century. And they make the accomplishments of the current government, led by Prime Minister Mark Rutte of the centre-right VVD party, even more impressive. Mr. Rutte's government was formed by a coalition with the centre-left PvdA party, and it is the first one since 2002 that has managed to serve its full term. His government's staying power has provided the Dutch people with some generally much-appreciated continuity and added a new consideration for voters contemplating making a wholesale change.

What the post-election government will look like

Now that the election results are known, and the VVD party has emerged victorious, we expect the current administration to continue more or less in its current form, with possibly a few more members added to its ranks.

The coalition's current members and prospective ones all seem to be united around the issue of education, and they are all pro-European Union. Of course, there are clearly big differences between these parties, so there will likely be protracted negotiations about the composition and objectives of the coalition. However, we do not believe this will prevent them from forming a pro-EU government - and possibly an even stronger one. As a result, we believe the Netherlands will not leave the EU any time soon.

Three core issues at stake

In the run-up to this election, security, migration and sovereignty were three of the biggest issues for Dutch voters.

The first two, security and migration, blurred together into one when terrorist attacks and Europe's migrant crisis undermined the Dutch government's credibility. Obviously, migration is a powerful issue throughout Europe, given German Chancellor Angela Merkel's stance on refugees and Germany's open-door policy. But in the Netherlands in particular, the anti-Islam, euro-sceptic PVV party found surprising support for its calls to limit migration, close mosques and ban the Koran from public buildings.

The other core issue for Dutch voters, sovereignty, was kept at the fore of the public's consciousness thanks to the EU's "freedom of movement" principle and Germany's response to the migrant crisis. Dutch voters had to grapple with the idea that being a member of the EU meant giving up sovereignty, and the populists' agenda gained some undeniable strength in this area. The Dutch system of proportional representation means that undeniably populist issues such as the freedom of movement and the future of migration will continue to influence both the domestic political agenda and the debate over the future of Europe.

A strong domestic economy

Overall, the Netherlands is in good shape economically and forms a strong member at the core of Europe. The gross domestic product of the Netherlands has returned to levels last seen before the Great Financial Crisis, with growth of approximately 2.1 per cent projected for 2017; meanwhile, its debt burden of around 64 per cent of GDP is even lower than Germany's. In addition, the Netherlands' ratio of sovereign debt to GDP is declining, thanks in part to higher-than-expected tax revenue last year, and thanks also to the re-privatization proceeds from banks nationalized after the crisis.

The monetary policies of the European Central Bank are cause for some concern for the Netherlands; the Dutch and Germans have seen their own central banks "lend" huge sums to the ECB's central-payment system, known as Target 2 - actions that effectively bailed out the weaker euro-zone members. Yet since September 2016, the Netherlands has seen their surplus Target 2 balance deteriorate. This suggests that the EU is more sensitive to political developments than previously thought, and that the markets are trying to protect themselves from a populist surprise in the Netherlands' elections.

In terms of the Netherlands' tax system, we do not expect significant changes to be implemented; however, if anti-EU parties were to gain traction in a coalition, their anti-free- trade stance could cause corporate taxes to rise.

Markets must become less narrow-minded

The uproar over a proposed merger of two major postal services in the region suggests there may be underlying hostility toward other kinds of regional consolidation, which the Dutch marketplace has benefitted from in the past. As a result, some corporations in the Netherlands have sought to unwind their interests in other countries as they encounter an unwelcoming environment at home, which could make the Dutch equity market less dynamic.

Overall, the journey to the "United States of Europe" requires local or national sentiment to become less narrow-minded so that European consumers can access better services at better prices, and so corporations can benefit from the economies of scale that Europe offers.

Fixed-income investors should find that the Dutch government's prudence is successfully keeping sovereign-bond supplies low, which should suppress yields and keep prices high. At the same time, investors in the Netherlands' equity and credit markets will find that issues are driven more by strong international exposure than by the local economy - which, again, is doing well.

Key considerations for investors

Anti-EU sentiment in the Netherlands did not significantly increase during the campaign, though anti-Islam feelings certainly grew. Yet despite rising support for populism, we believe there is little chance the Netherlands will leave the EU or the euro, since the Dutch are well aware that their strong economy is dependent on trade.

If we consider the European Commission's most recent Eurobarometer, which monitors changes in public opinion in the EU's member states, the Netherlands is not the most euro-sceptic country. As the accompanying chart shows, the Netherlands is less sceptical of the EU than France, Italy and the UK, but more sceptical than Germany and Spain.

All told, although investors globally seem to have shaken off the political surprises of 2016 with incredible nonchalance, European elections have the potential to deliver more market shocks this year. However, the Netherlands' markets have remained sanguine, which is probably due to the fact that they are underpinned by attractive credit fundamentals that have helped the country maintain its triple-A credit rating.

Globally, equity markets should now turn their attention to elections in France, Germany and possibly Italy, looking for any notable swings in sentiment. Investors should also watch closely for any resolution of the ongoing Greek debt problem, and for issues arising over the ECB's Target 2 balances; either one would have political ramifications for the Netherlands given that its central bank has lent a significant amount of money to the peripheral countries.

Overall, the Netherlands will be one of the key parties involved in the debate over the future of Europe, helping to determine whether there will be more muddling-through, whether Europe will build a "coalition of the willing" or if we will eventually see the creation of a European super-state.