Originally published on May 8, 2017
I use the research site GuruFocus almost daily. It's my go-to source for fundamental stock research, and the screeners and graphing tools alone would be well worth the subscription cost.
So, I was thrilled to find out that GuruFocus founder Charlie Tian, PhD, recently authored a book, Invest Like a Guru: How To Generate Higher Returns At Reduced Risk With Value Investing.
Tian doesn't have a background in finance. He's a scientist with a PhD in physics and an expert in fiber optics and lasers. Perhaps because of his unorthodox background, Tian approaches the investing process in a scientific way, picking apart the strategies of successful investors to see how they work. Much of Invest Like a Guru... - and GuruFocus too, for that matter - is focused on the strategies of wildly successful value investors such as Warren Buffett, Peter Lynch and Donald Yacktman.
The dominant theme of the book is quality. Buffett famously said "It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price," and Tian spends most of Invest Like a Guru... expanding on that core idea. Chapter 6 is particularly useful as a 20-point checklist of criteria to look for when seeking out quality companies, including consistent profitability, capital efficiency and insider ownership.
But while Invest Like a Guru... is full of solid advice in what to look for in a stock, it's far more useful in telling you what to avoid. As a case in point, Tian dedicates a chapter to deep-value investing, and I personally consider this the most important chapter in the book. I myself have gotten suckered into deep-value plays in the past, and they rarely seem to work out as planned or on the time frame I had hoped.
Deep-value investing is what Warren Buffett called "buying dollar bills for 40 cents" earlier in his career. Later, he mostly eschewed the strategy, calling it "cigar-butt" investing.
The rationale is easy enough to understand: It's hard to lose money buying a company that is worth more dead than alive. If a company's net assets are worth significantly more than its current market price, management could sell off the company for spare parts and deliver a decent profit to shareholders. And generally, that would be the right move. Remember, if a stock is trading that cheaply, chances are high that it is a company with very deep problems.
The problem is that it never quite works out that way. Monetizing assets is messy and complicated, and management has a vested interest in keeping the enterprise going. And the longer they do, the more value gets eroded.
As a case in point, consider the case of Sears Holdings (SHLD). Eddie Lampert and Bruce Berkowitz - both respected value investors - have effectively bet their careers on Sears in the belief that its real estate and brand portfolios represented massive untapped value. They problem is that the Sears retail business continues to deteriorate around them. They may eventually unlock the value they had hoped to, but it will have cost them dearly in money, reputational damage and - perhaps most importantly - opportunity cost. Had they focused their energies elsewhere, they might have made far better profits with far less headache.
Buffett himself learned the same lesson with Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A, BRK.B), which was a failing textile producer when Buffett originally bought it. Berkshire eventually failed, but only after Buffett had wasted untold time and energy (not to mention money) trying to keep it afloat. Buffett called his purchase of Berkshire Hathaway a "$100 billion mistake."
Tian finishes the chapter with the simple observation that "There are better ways to make money."
If you're new to value investing, I highly recommend Invest Like a Guru... But even if you're a seasoned investor, you'll find plenty of insightful food for thought. My compliments to Tian on a solid addition to the value investor's library.
This article first appeared on Sizemore Insights as Invest Like a Guru: How to Generate Higher Returns at Reduced Risk With Value Investing
Disclaimer: This site is for informational purposes only and should not be considered specific investment advice or as a solicitation to buy or sell any securities. Sizemore Capital personnel and clients will often have an interest in the securities mentioned. There is risk in any investment in traded securities, and all Sizemore Capital investment strategies have the possibility of loss. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. To view our full disclaimer please see Full Disclaimer