Seeking Alpha

Trouble Brewing In The 'SCANNZ Economies'


The SCANNZ economies share a common trait of having overvalued property markets, but that's not the only thing they have in common.

They are all relatively small open economies with independent central banks, and all have material sensitivity to exports and commodities.

The SCANNZ economies could come under 'simultaneous stress' if bond yields and borrowing costs rise sharply.

You've probably heard of the "BRIC economies" - the kings of the new paradigm in emerging markets - and no doubt are sick of hearing about the "PIIGS economies" - the Eurozone crisis culprits - but have you heard of the "SCANNZ economies"? This grouping of Sweden, Canada, Australia, Norway, and New Zealand on first glance seems like a disparate and haphazardly selected bunch, but they have more in common than you might think...

The chart for discussion comes from a deeper look at the so-called "SCANNZ economies" in a recent edition of the Weekly Macro Themes report, where I looked at the key risks, triggers, and vulnerabilities.

The chart below shows residential property market valuations for the SCANNZ economies, and should make it fairly easy to understand why I have grouped these countries together!

The key similarity that these countries share is overvalued property markets. But actually that's not where it stops. They all are relatively small, open economies, with their own currency, and an independent central bank. They also share a common feature of export sensitivity and undertake significant exports of commodities.

It's important to keep all of these factors in mind, because as I will explain, they tie intimately into the property market situation.

Through the 2000s the SCANNZ economies underwent major property price booms, culminating in overvalued housing markets. Around 2014-15 commodity markets went into tailspin and global trade slumped - naturally the central banks of the SCANNZ economies cut interest rates.

What happens to housing markets when you cut interest rates? People can borrow more, and they do, and house prices go up. What's interesting is that all 5 of these economies didn't really see a major reset in valuations in the wake of the financial crisis, so when you got this second wave of housing appreciation, it took already overvalued markets and extended them even further.

So now we have what at first glance is an eclectic grouping of countries from opposite corners of the world, which share common vulnerabilities (commodity prices and interest rates).

It's worth honing in on that last point - the SCANNZ economies are particularly sensitive to a rise in bond yields and borrowing costs. I wouldn't go so far as to call them PIIGS 2.0, and certainly there's probably less scope for contagion... but simultaneous stress is certainly a possibility for the SCANNZ economies. So it's an interesting, if unusual, one to keep on the risk radar.



BRIC = Brazil, Russia, India, China

PIIGS = Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece, Spain

This article originally appeared as a submission at See It Market

Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.