The New Social Status

|
Includes: AAPL, AIRB, FB, LVMHF, LYV, P, RACE, TRIP
by: GreenWood Investors
Summary

Throughout different cultural periods, status has meant different things.

With the invention of social media, how status was determined changed in the most dramatic sense.

As social status moves towards what you do, not what you have, the economy of "stuff" is giving way to the Experiences economy.

This article was inspired by a talk that our friend Adam Sebba at Cookson Adventures gave in Azerbaijan last month. The text and slides are available towards the end of this article. Thank you, Adam, for a highly engaging discussion!

Evolving Social Status

Social status has been one of the primary drivers of human behavior since the earliest days of civilization. Throughout different cultural periods, status has meant different things. In Roman times, it was most honorable to have land and serve in the military, hence the farmer was one of the most exulted roles a Roman could occupy. Then later, in the Middle Ages (for the Western world), as empires disintegrated along with trade routes and geographical mobility, the Catholic church came to be the most desirable institution to penetrate. The church saw this development as a monetization opportunity and sold nearly any role or any degree of forgiveness to the highest bidder. It took its monopoly status so far that it invoked Martin Luther and the Reformation to push back against the overt corruption of the wealthiest in society at the time.

Until the enlightenment movement and the semi-global revolutions against monarchies, status then tended to be determined by one's family name. Then, with the founding of America, enlightenment ideals were ensconced in a government contract, and society and family heritage went into a multi-century decline in importance. Even in the early days of the United States, when it was just a rag tag group of scrappy colonies, status was partially determined by service to the country, but also importantly by the wealth of the person. Wealth came to summarize one's contribution to society and colonial development. To summarize brashly, we tied social status to our spending power, and therefore, our social status was determined by where we lived, what we wore and later, what we drove. All personal interactions we had with friends and acquaintances were characterized by what we looked like and, perhaps, how we got there. Sometimes we would have friends over to our habitat to eat or celebrate, where we could show off more stuff. And that was the extent of our interaction with our social circles. That was the environment by which we formed judgements of our friends.

Then, with the invention of social media, all of that changed in the most dramatic sense.

I must caveat that while I was an early adopter of Facebook (FB), when it was still confined to college students, I have shunned social media for the last decade. So, I can't claim to be a social media expert by any measure. But social media changed the window with which we have to judge our friends and acquaintances. For the first time in human history, we continuously interact with people while they are relaxing, while they are on vacation and while they are bored at their job.

The Experiences Economy

Quite rapidly, social status today has morphed from what car we drive and what handbag we have to what we do on a daily basis. Social media can also bring out the vain side of us, and for the ones that excel in this new digitalized interactive world, everyday life is curated, whether it's faked or real, and the part that gets shared is often magazine-ready. We laugh when we hear people saying that the Instagram shows someone's or something's authenticity, as much of social media is the opposite of authentic. So much human behavior has become what we have been increasingly calling "template behavior." In most "Save the date" photos or baby announcement photos, even the poses are all the same if you are properly keeping up with the Joneses. Being a Stepford wife used to be shunned, now it is fully embraced.

Old stereotypes we would use to judge people have also evaporated. Former negative social signals such as "living in the middle of nowhere and driving an old Subaru" are now the same friends that have organic farms of some sort, their daily lives are picture-perfect, while the Manhattan sky rains down on the rest of us with bone-chilling temperatures and no camera filter. They are clearly happier than us. And they are absolutely the kings of the new social hierarchy. Perhaps the most self-conscious humans on the planet - adolescents - not only no longer care what car they drive to school or around town, they don't even bother to get their driver's license anymore. The cool kids of today are no longer the BMW drivers.

Exhibit 1: New Drivers Licenses in Spain

As authentic engagement has declined, our craving for in-person interaction has surged. Witness the fact that us and a record number of fellow investors continue to make the annual pilgrimage to Omaha during the Berkshire meeting, despite the fact we could all watch it online in bed at home without the $300/night LaQuinta Inn experience (bring your shower shoes). We need the interaction with our peers and friends. And we pay quite a price for the experience.

This development is not new, it's just accelerating. Just a few years after the invention of Facebook, we first heard this movement articulated by Pandora (P) co-founder Tim Westergren in a Wall Street Journal interview called "Pandora's Radio Head." Tim noted, "With increasing technology, people will actually go to concerts more than ever. The irony of technology is you become on one hand more connected, on the other hand more disconnected. People are going to yearn for that real, live human engagement."

That comment thankfully drove us to looking at Live Nation (LYV) as a potential investment, which was then out of favor, as the concert industry is a late-cycle business and had not yet turned up from the Global Financial Crisis. Tim helped us make quite a nice return from our sub-$9 purchase price on the stock. We unfortunately no longer own the global concert monopoly, as favorable returns, a rich valuation and an enthusiastic consensus caused us to sell way too soon.

Yet, there is another John Malone-related company we purchased under deeply unpopular conditions, and remains one of our favorite positions today.

TripAdvisor FTW

While Live Nation dominates the global concert industry, TripAdvisor (TRIP) is the number one site people use around the world to find travel inspiration, figure out where to go and, more importantly, what to do when they get there. In a clever evolution, the company has now allowed its >3 billion users or >400 million monthly active users to see what their friends recommend they do the next time they visit New York, Paris or Thailand. The company has the most data on travelers, by far the largest base of organic traffic and app downloads, the largest dataset on traveler preferences through its 700 million reviews, and increasingly has the largest inventory of bookable experiences and restaurants.

Exhibit 2: Bookable Inventory of Experiences and Restaurants

The company has doubled down on its massive lead and has accelerated its operating and marketing expenses in this division at a very robust clip. Short-term oriented investors have voted with their feet and traded the stock down, but we believe the company should not focus on profit-maximizing this segment where it has a very significant lead versus peers. It should do exactly what management has been doing, which is value-maximize the opportunity. We have the potential to become a global monopoly for in-destination experience discovery and booking, currently a $150 billion market (revenue available for online booking agents being $20-35 billion). While our investment is, of course, not contingent upon this blue sky scenario coming true, it surely is within grasp while consumer habits and behavior have not yet formed. Only a minuscule few percentage of in-destination experiences are being booked online. This is our market to lose.

Already, we are generating 14x the revenue from experiences than Airbnb (AIRB) is, despite the unicorn dumping a tremendous level of resources and attention into growing this segment. There are a lot of Softbank (OTCPK:SFTBY)-funded startups that are trying to make a dent in the industry, and while we welcome their awareness-building, they are all giving up on trying to compete on inventory, as we are pulling away from the pack with at least a 5x advantage. Ubiquity of inventory has been a key "killer app" for all online e-commerce businesses, so a mass market business like GetYourGuide trying to focus on "unique" experiences looks set for failure. If someone has waited a year to travel to Hawaii, they will want to make sure they book the best snorkeling tour available, not just the only one available on a fringe platform. The only way to eliminate the FOMO risk is to book with the partner that has everything. We believe tour operators will either need to focus on highly tailored unique experiences or will need to offer all mass market options, and there is little room for the bookers in the middle.

If you don't believe Malone or Masa about the opportunity here as consumption converts from things to experiences, just look at where the chairman of LVMH (OTCPK:LVMHF), Bernard Arnaud, the third wealthiest man in the world and the king of "selling status," is spending his capital.

Selling Status

LVMH has masterfully built an irreplaceable collection of brands that sell products to elevate its customers' lifestyles and social status. Yet, as social status moves towards what you do, not what you have, the economy of "stuff" is giving way to the Experiences economy. Perhaps the best validation of this is LVMH's large and high-valued purchase of Belmond Resorts. Belmond is just as much an Experiences curator as it is a high-end resort. While travelers can book just a few nights at one of its hotels, the company tries to package experiences throughout its collection of assets, whether it be a luxury train ride through jungles or mountains, or curated photo excursions with Leica-sponsored world-class photographers. This is perhaps the best-scaled luxury tour operator of one-of-a-kind experiences, sunsets on the Serengeti or moonrises over the Mediterranean.

Exhibit 3: Just one of Belmond's Experiences

Another of our investments, Ferrari (RACE), has built its entire ecosystem on offering unique and world-class bespoke experiences to its highly loyal Ferraristi. Because its clients are buying a full ecosystem and year-round invitation-only events, while the monetization may occur, like Apple's (AAPL), through hardware, the hardware is really just one of the many reasons why its clients remain highly loyal.

"The impulse to travel is one of the hopeful symptoms of life."

- Agnes Repplier

Editor’s Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.