In mid-December, Cineplex (OTCPK:CPXGF) announced a friendly takeover deal that will see Cineworld Group (OTCPK:CNNWF or OTCPK:CNWGY ) purchase Cineplex for $34 (in CDN) a share. This represented a 42% premium at the time, but the stock had traded above $34 from mid-2013 to late 2017. To sell at a $34 price, quite a bit of value has been given up here.
In its most recent Q3 quarterly earnings update, Cineplex's management highlighted the following:
With the company enjoying such success, why sell a company now that was at one period trading at $50?
I can only think of a few reasons why:
Over the years, I have been bullish on Cineplex because of its attitude to wanting to try something new. In the last decade and a bit, Cineplex had made efforts to be more than just a movie theater company:
This diversification strategy has shifted its business where more than 20% of its total revenue now comprises of Media / Amusement / Other:
(Source: 2018 Annual Report)
In all ventures, not every hit is a home run. Recently, Cineplex has disclosed in its latest earnings call that it is looking for a strategic equity partner for its online eSports business.
Profits in its media division have been low because of low installation revenues.
Revenue from its Rec Room restaurants is expected to come down because of the honeymoon period of 12 to 18 months.
Although revenue growth across all areas have improved over the prior year. It appears the Amusement division is seeing slowing sales momentum:
(Source: Cineplex Financials)
These minor hiccups combined with a gradual decline in theater attendance had punished the stock's value in the last 2 years. But in the last 5 years, Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA Margins remain strong and consistent:
(Source: 2018 Annual Report)
Financially, Cineplex was still posting strong numbers but the narrative had changed 2 years ago that the movie theater industry is dying because of new streaming services. This is likely the reason why the stock could not regain its former value and nothing management did could change that.
Taking a friendly takeover offer of $34 per share was the quickest way to creating the highest value.
There are economies of scale in having a larger theater chain network. A larger theater chain network puts it in a stronger negotiating position with movie studios especially when movie studios are also consolidating itself.
Cineplex acquired Famous Players in 2005 and purchased 24 Empire theaters in Atlantic Canada in 2013. Buying out its competitors has always been a part of Cineplex's strategy and this was what positioned it into a national chain. So a sale to a much bigger theater operator with a network across the globe seems like a natural progression.
This friendly takeover is subject to the Investment Canada Act. Since Cineworld is a foreign corporate entity, its acquisition still needs to go through regulatory approval.
There have already been complaints in the Canadian film circles that a Cineplex sale would hurt the Canadian film market, because there could be less opportunities for Canadian films to be shown on theater screens now.
How the political winds blow on this deal is rather hard to say. I'm not sure how the Canadian government would view a foreign entity owning more than 75% of Canada's theater business. I think it is likely the deal will go through but politics is always hard to guess.
I can understand Cineplex's angle in this but I also can't help but wonder whether management had pulled the trigger to sell too early. There are merits to selling itself to gain more clout on the bargaining table. But I don't think there was enough time for its non-theater businesses to play out.
Its Junxion concept announced in November 2019 to build a food hall with food trucks, surrounded by video and redemption games has appeal. It has the potential to be a game changer but since it is not theater business related, would Cineworld nix these plans after its acquisition? It is possible.
Cineplex has until Feb 2, 2020 to find a better offer. A better offer would probably come from another theater operator but to come up with the financing at such a short time is difficult. Realistically, the likelihood of a better offer is low since this is a friendly takeover so it has the blessing of both Cineplex and Cineworld management.
In light of what is going on in the industry and the mixed results Cineplex has made to diversify itself, I think $34 a share is a fair deal. I don't think it is the best but it isn't bad either.
This article was written by
Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.