5 Reasons Why You Should Avoid Nutanix
Summary
- Nutanix stock is less than 30% of what it was in 2018. It is currently very undervalued.
- There are alarm bells that investors should be aware of, including negative free cash flow, negative total common equity, and extremely high SG&A expense.
- I suggest waiting for the company to complete transformation to subscription and for the pandemic/recession to play out before investing.
- Looking for a portfolio of ideas like this one? Members of Digital Transformation get exclusive access to our model portfolio. Get started today »
Nutanix, Inc. (NASDAQ:NTNX) once was considered a very promising high growth stock investment and a leader in the hyper-converged infrastructure market once had a CAGR in excess of 40%.
(Source: Nutanix)
But the company has embarked on its own transformation from hardware to software subscription at an accelerated pace, "clouding" its performance over the short term (Sorry for the pun). Conversion from point-of-sale to subscription gives the appearance of reduced revenue growth and compressed margins until the transformation is complete.
This is one reason why Nutanix stock has been beaten up. After reaching an all-time high of ~$60 in the summer of 2018, the stock price has been in decline ever since and now trades near $18.
(Source: Yahoo Finance/MS Paint)
While many analysts consider the stock to be severely undervalued at present, I urge investors to be cautious as the pandemic and recession play out. Below I am providing 5 reasons why you might want to hold off on investing in Nutanix this year.
Negative Free Cash Flow Margin
Nutanix has a history of negative free cash flow. While it briefly turned positive in January of 2019, it is now plummeting. The CFO indicated in February that the company planned for ~-$250 million in free cash flow in 2020. This was before the full effect of COVID-19 was known or appreciated.
(Source: Portfolio123/MS Paint)
High Level of SG&A Expenses
Nutanix has an extremely high level of SG&A expenses relative to sales, 140% to be exact.
Note: SG&A expense margin includes R&D and associated stock-based compensation.
(Source: Portfolio123)
This means that the company is spending 40% more on SG&A plus R&D than its revenue intake. It is unlikely that Nutanix will have positive earnings for the foreseeable future, and given the current global environment, losses could be much higher than in the past.
The management indicated in the Q2 2020 earnings call that they would not slow down on hiring salespeople:
...we mentioned that we're not pausing sales teams. So that's very important that that comes across clearly. We'll continue to hire sales teams, because any downturn period, the worst thing in my mind you can do is halt sales teams, because -- so you have a little pause. In this case, it's completely out of our hands. I think we're being prudent.
But if you start pausing on sales teams then it takes you twice as long to get back to an accelerated growth, because then you got to go hire folks and ramp them and things like that. So we'll continue with the vast majority of our sales teams hiring there.
Negative Total Common Equity
I have recently started tracking total common equity as a fundamental factor, specifically looking for companies with negative total common equity. I discovered one company with negative common equity recently. Nutanix is another, turning negative in the most recent quarter.
(Source: Portfolio123/MS Paint)
This is a situation that I don't normally run across, so I decided to run a backtest of the stock performance of companies with negative common equity. Using the Russell 3000 as the base stock universe, I determined that stocks with negative total common equity have underperformed the Russell 3000 fairly significantly over the last 10 years.
(Source: Portfolio123/MS Paint)
Excessive Stock-Based Compensation
Excessive stock-based compensation (SBC) is something that almost all software companies have in common. But Nutanix has much higher SBC than most companies. A typical software company will provide SBC within the range of 5-15% of revenue. For the first 6 months of FY20, Nutanix has given out $167 million in SBC whereas revenue was $662 million or SBC which amounts to 25% of revenue.
(Source: Nutanix)
While some would argue that SBC is not relevant because it is non-cash compensation, it has the effect of making both investors and employees unhappy when the stock is underperforming as is the case with Nutanix.
Concentration of Revenue and Accounts Receivable
The final point that I would like to make for today is that Nutanix depends almost entirely on partners for sales. And there is little diversification on this front. One partner account for 30% of revenue and 28% of accounts receivable. The second most important partner accounts for 13% of revenue and 14% of accounts receivable.
(Source: Nutanix)
In normal times, this lack of diversification may not be of concern, but in the present circumstances, the failure of a partner could cause significant harm to Nutanix's business.
Summary and Conclusions
Nutanix is a leader in the hyper-converged infrastructure market and, prior to the start of its transformation to a subscription-based business model, was growing at an impressive rate of 40% per annum. But the transformation has clouded the company's performance. It may very well be that Nutanix returns to being a high-growth company once the transition is complete and, of course, after the pandemic and recession play out.
But, I suggest that investors take a cautious approach. While the company is undervalued at present, it has negative free cash flow, negative total common equity, and an extremely high SG&A expense margin. In addition, the company's SBC is exceptionally high and revenue generation is not diversified among channel partners.
Digital Transformation is a once-in-a-lifetime investment opportunity fueled by the need for businesses to convert to the new digital era or risk being left behind. You can take advantage of this opportunity by subscribing to the Digital Transformation marketplace service.
This article was written by
I have been trading stocks, commodities, and options for more than 25 years. I have honed my skills in quantitative analysis and various stock investment tools for 15 years at Portfolio123 and offer services as a consultant in stock portfolios. I also own the financial data service Equity Analytx which provides aggregated fundamentals for a wide range of industries.
Analyst’s Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
Seeking Alpha's Disclosure: Past performance is no guarantee of future results. No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment is suitable for a particular investor. Any views or opinions expressed above may not reflect those of Seeking Alpha as a whole. Seeking Alpha is not a licensed securities dealer, broker or US investment adviser or investment bank. Our analysts are third party authors that include both professional investors and individual investors who may not be licensed or certified by any institute or regulatory body.
Recommended For You
Comments (28)
Will it ever be compared with CRM or ADBE or what is your thought?
i do own NTNX, some at low 18s, and I am frustrated at them dropping the ball on certain things I chalk it up to growing pains, like adobe but not as successful but also not as bleak as you have indicated. With their lower overhead (since laying off a bunch of.. perhaps not best skilled EEs) their next quarter can be better than this one. Adobe had to wait many quarters before seeing the change in billing models come to fruition. With the economy strengths shifting to remote and technology I would rather own this then USO, cars, ships, rigs
I am in IT and have significant insight into company's positive aspects too. I think company had flaws but has made corrections and even got new big deals which they will prob disclose in upcoming earnings. Its on growth trajectory right now. The stock is destined to go up tomorrow and a lot more up in coming days.
We have Nutanix equipment and its transformative for DB Web Apps and IT. But these issues are real and company plan is to invest in high growth now and market share. If so these negatives will pay off in the long run
Short Interest (Shares Short) 12,410,000
Short Interest (Shares Short) - Prior 11,220,000% From 52-Wk High ($ 40.10) -56.01%
% From 50-Day MA ($ 18.79) -6.14%
% From 200-Day MA ($ 26.02) -32.21%
% From 52-Wk Low ($ 11.31) 55.97%
52-Week Performance -54.40%NTNX and its crew's performance? BEYOND ABYSMAL!
When you make an analysis about a company it would be great to speak about the growth prospects, about the potential impact in this situation and about the valuation at this point in time.
You are completly right, there are things to be cautious about but the P/S ratio is 2.65 at the Moment so don't you think most of your points are priced in? If not, what would your target be for a market leader in this segment? In my view your analysis is just a list of possible landmines (are they really? What are the effects of negative common equity in one month?) to justify your prefabricated opinion about a stock.
Top execs turnover indicates company is rotting from within. Trouble is they never get rid of bad apples like CIO. There are numerous articles praising her achievements and care for employees but she's inhumane and clueless.
My wrongful job termination in their IT Swamp is a result of it. They did not give a damn about innovations coming from a person with over 25 years of open source software experience that was working very hard in their IT trench lines.
Nutanix is replacing Americans with inexperienced people from CEOs homeland. A number of engineers (?) came without "basic knowledge of Linux" to work as programmers on company core product. This is clear indication of high level of H-1B visa fraud.
Thanks for the article explaining negative cash flow Steve. I'll trim whatever was left after they stole 1/3rd of my ISOs 13 months ago. I already returned jacket and such with Nutanix logo to top execs. Nothing to be proud about NTNX anymore.