Style And Asset Class Rotation Is Taking Place

Summary

• As it relates to value versus growth performance one question becomes is this rotation to value and its outperformance sustainable and the start of a longer-term trend.
• We do believe the economy has exited the recession and is in a part of the business cycle where value has historically outperformed growth.
• Interest rate pressure to the upside is wanting to take hold as the inflation discussion increasingly makes headlines.

Photo by ipopba/iStock via Getty Images

For nearly three trading weeks, the S&P 500 Index has traded mostly sideways, somewhat expected after the fast start to 2021, i.e., the S&P 500 Index up over 11% through the end of April. Under the surface though the trading has not been so subdued. Several important trends are taking place investors might want to take note of.

First of all the so-called FANG trade has lagged the broader market since the beginning of September. The below chart displays the FANGMA stocks, i.e., Facebook (FB), Amazon (AMZN), Netflix (NFLX), Alphabet (GOOG) (GOOGL), Microsoft (MSFT) and Apple (AAPL) compared to the S&P 500 Index since September 1, 2020. The only FANGMA stock beating the Index is Alphabet with the other FANGMA stocks trailing the S&P 500 Index by double digits.

These mega-cap growth stocks have been a favorite of investors for the last eight or more years with each outperforming the broader market S&P 500 Index by a wide margin. With the FANGMA's lagging the market now, a rotation seems to be underway.

In the chart below the blue line represents the average return of these six FANGMA stocks compared to some additional asset classes. The red line on the chart represents the small cap iShares Russell 2000 ETF (IWM) and the pink line is the iShares Core S&P Mid-Cap ETF (IJH). Both of these asset classes are far outpacing the average return of the FANGMA basket and outpacing the S&P 500 Index. This type of rotation is healthy for the market as a broader group of stocks are participating in the market's move higher.

The stocks in the FANGMA basket tend to be classified as growth stocks versus value stocks. Since the end of the 2008/2009 financial crisis pure growth stocks have outperformed pure value. Again, since September 1, 2020 the Pure Value Style (RPV) has far outpaced Pure Growth (RPG). The below chart clearly shows this with the S&P 500 Pure Value Index returning 54.7% versus the Pure Growth Index counterpart returning 14.5%.

As it relates to value versus growth performance one question becomes is this rotation to value and its outperformance sustainable and the start of a longer-term trend. Without having a clear crystal ball, where the economy seems to be in the economic cycle can provide some clarity.

We do believe the economy has exited the recession and is in a part of the business cycle where value has historically outperformed growth as I have written about in the past in an article titled, Why It Matters Value Stocks Are Outperforming Growth Stocks.

Another variable that can lead to value outperformance is the direction of interest rates as seen in the below chart. As longer-term rates rise and the yield curve steepens, this typically is a common occurrence as the economy exits a recession. And with higher longer-term interest rates, this can create a headwind for growth stocks since their more distant earnings and cash flow are worth less as they are discounted forward at higher interest rates.

The below chart shows this steeper yield curve relationship. As the yield curve has steepened, value has mostly outperformed growth and has taken hold since October of 2020.

In conclusion, interest rate pressure to the upside is wanting to take hold as the inflation discussion increasingly makes headlines. Much of this inflation pressure seems to be due to tight inventories coming out of the pandemic shutdown. The overused terms is this current inflation is transitory. The pent-up demand will get satisfied and maybe a lot of it not until mid year next year. However, we do not believe significant inflation takes hold longer term, at least at this point in time.

Original Post

Editor's Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.

Comments

[manfac]

Style and Asset Class are you covering up the anomaly of quantitative versus qualitative ?

I wish you would be more deeper in your pronouncement ; here is mine.

Style is the dispersion of matters over size , genderless and more emotion and finally legacy and longevity .

Asset Class is borderless and factual , multi-faceted and novice , and finally you got`it and very public .

I think your article is complete now that I put in my two bits worth .

[A Young Financial Advisor]

David hello! Thank you for all the great articles. A question for you and your experience. Do you think is too late to jump into the value trade? I started heavily investing in tech in late December and Jan-March of 2021 into tech stocks. I have very little exposure to more traditional/value plays. The only significant value play I have is the XLF. Does the value trade has some more room to run or should I wait in cash? My tech portfolio is down like 12% most of my ark investments are down 20 or more percent but taking all the growth exposure the little value I have and the hedge funds + cash I am flat on my portfolio while the indices are all time high....What would you recommend me doing? Is it too late to enter value? How long does value over performance on growth lasts? Do you have any idea on mutual funds or etfs that I could put some of the cash. Or the best thing to do is wait? Thank you in advance

[Chip Chipperson]

@A Young Financial Advisor Fidelity ZERO funds for your ETFs. FNILX or FZROX are nice. Drop ARK funds like a hot rock! The valuations are absurd. Most of those companies are pure speculation with almost no chance of ever becoming profitable. Wood is the flavor of the day, but know that the macro environment is exposing the flaws in her aggressive style. In 2-3 years, she'll be a pariah on the Street.