Capital Southwest: 40 Big-Dividend BDCs Compared

Jan. 29, 2022 9:00 AM ETCapital Southwest (CSWC)56 Comments

Summary

  • Popular in certain niche investment circles, this big-dividend BDC remains a hidden gem for others.
  • A few attractive qualities of this smaller small cap include its healthy business, internal management team, SBIC license and strong dividend position.
  • Rising interest rates remain a risk, but the company has attractive floating rate exposures, and the risks are already baked in, to a significant extent.
  • We dive into the details, including a comparison of Capital Southwest to 40 other big-dividend BDCs, and then conclude with a couple critical takeaways for investors.
  • This idea was discussed in more depth with members of my private investing community, Big Dividends PLUS. Learn More »

Big Savings

Big Dividends PLUS, by Blue Harbinger

Altayb/E+ via Getty Images

For many, Capital Southwest (NASDAQ:CSWC) remains a bit of a hidden gem in the big- dividend BDC space. However, this small cap has many of the important qualities you'd like to see in a BDC (such as internal management, strong NII and a healthy dividend), plus the growing macroeconomic interest rate risks are already baked in-to a significant extent. In this report, we dive into the important details (ahead of its upcoming earnings release on January 31st), including a comparison of Capital Southwest to 40 other big-dividend BDCs. We conclude with a couple critical takeaways for investors.

CSWC

Capital Southwest Corporation

Capital Southwest Corporation

Overview: Capital Southwest (CSWC)

CSWC is a middle-market lending firm focused on supporting the acquisition and growth of middle-market companies across the capital structure. The company is based in Dallas Texas, it was formed in 1961, and it elected to be regulated as a BDC in 1988. It is publicly traded (on Nasdaq). And importantly, Capital Southwest is internally managed (this eliminates many conflicts of interest that plague other BDCs). Further, CSWC has RIC tax treatment for U.S. federal income tax purposes, which means it can basically avoid corporate income tax if it pays out 90% of income as dividends.

Also noteworthy, in September of 2015 CSWC completed a tax-free spin off of CSW Industrials (CSWI), and this helped clean up the business (so it could focus on lending to middle-market companies, instead of equity investments).

Also important to mention, in April 2021, CSWC received an SBIC license from the U.S. Small Business Administration (this provides some loan support, thereby opening up new attractive risk-reward lending opportunities).

Also, CSWC has only 24 employees (the market cap of the business is only around $550 million-it's a smaller small cap), and total balance sheet assets were $867 MM as of September 30, 2021. Additionally, and importantly, CSWC also manages the I-45 Senior Loan Fund ("I-45 SLF") in partnership with Main Street Capital (MAIN).

Capital Southwest Corporation

Capital Southwest Corporation

Capital Southwest Corporation

Also important (considering CSWC's small size versus some other BDCs), the company continues to achieve operating efficiencies (thanks to its internal management structure) that continue to flow through to its bottom line (as you can see in the graphic below).

Capital Southwest Corporation

Capital Southwest Corporation

Capital Southwest Corporation

Capital Southwest Compared 40 Other Big-Dividend BDCs

Before getting into more detail on Capital Southwest, it's worth considering some data on 40 big-dividend BDCs, including CSWC. The following tables show important BDCs metrics, including dividend yields, recent price performance and current versus historical price-to-book and Return on Equity ("ROE"), to name a few.

The Blue Harbinger Weekly

data as of Friday's close 1/28/22

The Blue Harbinger Weekly

Herrick Lake Investments

data as of Friday's close 1/28/22

The Blue Harbinger Weekly

Herrick Lake Investments

data as of Friday's close 1/28/22

The Blue Harbinger Weekly

While the above data is valuable, keep in mind that BDCs can have widely different investment strategies, thereby warranting significantly different valuation metrics. For example, the lowest price-to-book value isn't necessarily the best; rather it can be an indication of higher risk (we'll get into CSWC's investment strategy momentarily).

Capital Southwest's Investment Strategy

The company's core lending business is focused on lower middle market ("LMM") in what it terms "CSWC led or Club Deals". These are typically companies with EBITDA between $3 MM and $20 MM, and typical leverage of 2.0x - 4.0x Debt to EBITDA (through CSWC's debt position). They make commitment sizes up to $30 MM (with hold sizes generally $10 MM to $25 MM), including both sponsored and non-sponsored deals. Securities include first lien, unitranche, and second lien. And the companies frequently make equity co-investments alongside CSWC's debt.

The company's opportunistic business is focused on upper middle market ("UMM") in syndicated or club, first and second liens. Companies typically have in excess of $20 MM in EBITDA; and typical leverage of 3.0x - 5.5x Debt to EBITDA (through CSWC's debt position). Hold sizes are generally $5 MM to $15 MM, including floating rate first and second lien debt securities. These types of investments are generally more liquid assets relative to LMM investments. And this provides flexibility to invest/divest opportunistically based on market conditions and liquidity position.

Importantly, Capital Southwest's credit portfolio is heavily weighted towards first lien investments, which are less risky than second lien investments.

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

And the company has a strong history of value creation, which is not a guarantee of future performance, but it is still nice to see and adds confidence considering the longevity of the existing management team at CSWC.

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

Also encouraging, CSWC continues to be active in both originations and investment "exits," a sign of healthy market conditions and opportunities for the business. For example, in the most recent quarter, CSWC had $112.9 MM in total new committed investments to six new portfolio companies and four existing portfolio companies, and $60.9 MM in total proceeds from six portfolio company exit.

Track Record Of Consistent Dividends Continues

Another encouraging characteristic of Capital Southwest is its track record of consistent and healthy dividends. For example, over the last 12 months (ended 9/30/21), CSWC generated $1.85 per share in Pre-Tax NII and paid out $1.70 per share in regular dividends. Furthermore, the cumulative pre-tax NII regular dividend coverage has been 107% (over 100% is good) since the 2015 Spin-Off. And very importantly, the total special and supplemental dividends of $3.41 per share since the 2015 Spin-Off. Also, there was undistributed taxable income ("UTI") of $0.69 per share as of September 30, 2021.

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

Interest Rate Risk

The big macroeconomic risk that currently has investors concerned across almost all markets is interest rate risk. Specifically, the US fed is on a trajectory to begin raising interest rates in March (with 3-4 hikes expected this year) while they simultaneously slow down the quantitative easing of open market bond purchases. This increasingly hawkish stance by the fed has had the impact of spooking stock market investors, as markets have broadly declined so far this year. This is also concerning for Capital Southwest's business, considering debt (borrowing) is impacted by interest rates and it is at the core of everything Capital Southwest does.

Here is a look at the company's estimate of its sensitivity to interest rate changes.

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

Capital Southwest Corp

As you can see above, CSWC is negatively impacted by rising interest rates because it has slightly more exposure to floating rates on the expense side than on the revenue side. However, given the recent decline in the share price of the CSWC, rising interest rate expectations are already significantly baked into the shares. If the fed becomes slightly more hawkish on rates, that could be a negative impact on CSWC shares, but if the fed becomes slightly more dovish then that would be a benefit to the shares. This is typical to financial companies, such as CSWC. Also noteworthy, CSWC is even more sensitive to credit spreads than interest rates because the portfolio consists of higher yield (higher risk loans). So in a volatile market, where credit spreads widen-CSWC would like sell off (likely temporarily), but the dividend would likely remain consistent as it has throughout its history.

Blue Harbinger

YCharts

YCharts

Regarding valuation, BDCs often trade in conjunction with their book value. In the case of CSWC, the valuation increased following the 2015 spin off, and it has recently pulled back as interest rate expectations have increased while credit spreads remained low/healthy.

Blue Harbinger

YCharts

YCharts

The Bottom Line

If you are looking for a hidden gem of a BDC, Capital Southwest is worth considering. It is smaller than many BDCs which arguably excludes the "economies of scale" advantages that larger companies have. However, this is significantly offset by the lower costs of its attractive internal management team, as well as its small business license (something that can move the needle for a smaller BDCs, but not for a larger one). The strength of the portfolio and healthy dividend are also highly encouraging, and the recent dip in share price makes for an even more compelling entry point. Depending on how the January 31st (post-market) earnings announcement goes, this one is worth considering for a spot in your prudently diversified long-term investment portfolio.

And if you are looking for more high-income investment ideas, you might consider our Big Dividends PLUS service. It offers a steady flow of high-income investment idea reports, plus you'll get access to the holdings in our 39-stock Income Equity Portfolio. While the S&P 500 and Nasdaq are down big this year, our portfolio is down only 2.4%, and it offers a current yield of nearly 6% (not to mention many of the stock ideas we share yield significantly more!).

*We're currently offering our max 45% Off Discount on all new annual subscriptions, but hurry because the discount won’t be available for long.

This article was written by

Blue Harbinger profile picture
15.56K Followers
Where Retirees and Income Investors Stay Sharp.
Free Reports: www.blueharbinger.com/free-reports.


- - - - - - - 

Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any specific securities, investments, or investment strategies. Investments involve risk and, unless otherwise stated, are not guaranteed. Be sure to first consult with a qualified financial adviser and/or tax professional before implementing any strategy discussed herein. Past performance is not indicative of future performance.

Disclosure: I/we have no stock, option or similar derivative position in any of the companies mentioned, but may initiate a beneficial Long position through a purchase of the stock, or the purchase of call options or similar derivatives in CSWC over the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recommended For You

Comments (56)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.