A High Level Of Investor Bearishness Might Lead To An Equity Market Bounce
- The total return for the S&P 500 Index through the first four months of the year has the index down -12.92%.
- April is generally one of the stronger months of the year, but this year’s April return goes against history.
- Lastly, S&P 500 company earnings have been favorable for the first quarter.
With the just-completed month of April, the first four months of 2022 have not been rewarding ones for investors. The total return for the S&P 500 Index through the first four months of the year has the index down -12.92%. Ryan Detrick of LPL Research looked at the price return for the index and this decline is the third-worst start to a year going back to 1928 as seen in the below table. Encouragingly, returns following a weak start to a year tend to be mostly positive.
What makes the current environment more difficult for investors is the fact bond returns have been almost as weak as equity returns. The Bloomberg Aggregate Total Return Bond Index is down nearly 10% through the first four months of this year and this is the worst performance for this index to start a year going back to the index's inception date in 1973. Longer maturity bonds have performed even worse with the iShares 20+ Year Treasury ETF (TLT) down -19.05% just this year.
April is generally one of the stronger months of the year, but this year’s April return goes against history. The second and third quarters of the second year in the presidential cycle tend to be the weaker ones, so investors might be in for a little more market volatility over the next quarter and a half. After the election though, some of the market’s strongest returns have been in the 12-month period following mid-term elections as we noted in an earlier Investor Letter.
The other variable that might provide an indication of a market bounce is the weakness being seen in some of the investor sentiment indicators. Last week’s American Association of Individual Investors (AAII) Sentiment Survey report showed individual bullish sentiment remains at a near-record low. Additionally, as seen in the second chart below, the bull/bear spread is at a level only seen a few other times in the Survey’s history, indicative of a high level of investor bearishness. With sentiment measures being contrarian ones, a market bounce might be forthcoming.
Lastly, S&P 500 company earnings have been favorable for the first quarter. Year-over-year (YoY) earnings growth is 10.1% for the 275 companies that have reported, ex-energy though the YoY increase is 4.4% and 80.4% of companies reporting have exceeded analyst earnings estimates. Revenues have been good as well, up 12.5% and ex-energy up 9.3%. Certainly, inflation is a tailwind for revenue growth, but this does make stocks a reasonable inflation hedge. Investors should expect more volatility, but investor bearishness is at a high level and this is one near-term positive for stocks.
Editor's Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.
This article was written by