LGI Homes Is Investing In Growth As Rates Rise

May 20, 2022 3:04 PM ETLGI Homes, Inc. (LGIH)DHI, LEN6 Likes

Summary

  • The ~35% fall for LGIH this year, like many homebuilders, is due to surging mortgage rates.
  • There are few signs of cooling sales so far and rental prices have also surged showing strong fundamental demand.
  • Higher house prices plus mortgage rates surging past 5% are quickly creating an affordability crisis that will eventually slow demand.
  • Valuations for LGI Homes price in these problems, but other homebuilders have similar ratios and lower leverage levels.

Pink wooden house model rests on piles of rusted nails. Heart shape. Homebuilding and repairing concept.

bombermoon/iStock via Getty Images

Right now, LGI Homes (NASDAQ:LGIH) is like a store with nearly empty shelves due to a crush of demand, desperately trying to restock the shelves. This effort will boost growth over coming quarters. Community count had dropped by ~20% as they sold out and needs to be replenished. That's a good problem.

However, LGIH management have gone bigger than just returning community count to an upwards trend. They've increased the land bank, particularly raw land, considerably. They have also spent $300M+ on share buy backs over the last few years while their shares were at record highs.

As rates rise, they may wish they had this cash around to cherry pick small distressed competitors rather than having to access increasingly expensive debt markets. Long term investors (and management) may regret their timing of land and share purchases.

We will explain in more detail. Here is your quick guide.

  1. Sales have dipped due to insufficient available stock.
  2. Sales rates have remained solid in 2022 so far.
  3. Restocking the land pipeline has gone into overdrive.
  4. Stock buy-backs have continued, contributing to rising debt levels.
  5. Mortgage rates are rising and increasing affordability problems.
  6. Rising rents and LGI Homes market position provide some protection.
  7. Valuation remains reasonable, but risks are rising.

Sales have dipped due to insufficient stock

LGI Homes, unlike most homebuilders, specializes in building a house and then selling it 'as is'. This enables prices to be lower yet margins to remain strong due to lower construction management costs of various option packages.

LGIH Quarterly Revenue

LGIH Quarterly Revenue (Caterer Goodman)

That big stampede of demand just destocked LGIH. You can see the impact as communities sold out and couldn't be replaced fast enough, below.

LGIH Community Count

LGIH Community Count (Caterer Goodman)

By this point, LGIH should have, if it kept to it's long term trend, about 118 communities operating rather than just 88. Returning communities to it's previous trend has, understandably, become a focus of management as we will see a bit later. That's because demand remained firm.

Sales rates have remained solid in 2022 so far

To see the state of the market, it is better to look at the sales per community per month. As the figure shows, for Q1 the sales rate remains slightly above the average for a Q1 but down on Q1 2021.

LGIH Community Sales Month

LGIH Community Sales Month (Caterer Goodman)

An absorption rate of 6 per community per month is quite decent for a first quarter. Normal market conditions produce a range of 5 to 8 per month. Typically, Q4 is the strongest, as demand pulls forward to get people into homes by Christmas. Q1 2022 was acceptable and it looks like April continued that theme.

In the 2022 Q1 earnings call The CEO Eric Lipar gave an update on sales following quarter end, "(For April)...on 91 communities...the absorption pace of 7.7 closings per community exceeded our eight-year historical average for the fourth straight month this year."

Let's give more context to this sales rate.

This is a solid result compared to the pre-boom average. LGI Homes prefer the 2014-2020 average of 6-7 closings per community per month. That does seem like a fairer benchmark than the 2020-21 boom.

Absorption Rate per Region

Absorption Rate per Region (Caterer Goodman)

As the figure shows below the Central region is a region of strength and monthly absorption rate is the highest. However outside of this region the trend is gently but noticeably negative.

LGIH Revenue and Closings by Region

LGIH Revenue and Closings by Region (Caterer Goodman)

The Central region for LGIH is by far the most important. Despite efforts to expand geographically it represents around 40% of the company. That's a good thing. Texas is a good place to be during a period of high energy prices.

Restocking the land pipeline is in overdrive

From 2020 Q2 there has been a tremendous push to increase lots owned and controlled to well above the long term trend.

LGIH Lots Owned and Controlled

LGIH Lots Owned and Controlled (Caterer Goodman)

However this push might not see an immediate increase in communities as CFO Charles Merdian explained in the latest earnings call, " ...as we move inventory into owned, we are still predominantly seeing...raw land deals. So... (we'll have) to spend that cash to get those sections ready, as we've been talking about delivering community count into 2023 and 2024."

So expect both further cash costs before a burst of new communities in 2023 and 2024. It does make us wonder... what will rates be at that point?

Stock buy-backs have contributed to rising debt

LGI Homes is the 10th largest home builder by revenue* but by launching stock buy backs it seems keen to play with the big boys, despite being only about 10% the size of the leaders, D.R. Horton (DHI) and Lennar (LEN) by both sales and net income.

LGIH Buybacks and Buyback ratio

LGIH Buybacks vs Net Income (Caterer Goodman)

*By profits LGI Homes ranks around 7th.

As the figure above shows, LGI Homes has increased the repurchase payout ratio from around 30% to 73% in the most recent quarter.

We'd argue that combining stock buy backs in 2020 and 2021 with a big investment in land at this time of the cycle might not be the best decision. The repurchases that spent $330+ million in cash could be very handy soon.

It has also led to LGIH's debt load to rebound quickly.

LGIH Debt to Capitalization Rate

LGIH Debt to Capitalization Rate (Caterer Goodman)

To be fair, LGIH has always had a higher debt load than other large builders. A rate of 40% is not yet dangerously high either.

But other home builders are better placed should the property market slow drastically. Given the inflation outlook, this remains quite possible.

Homebuilder Debt to Capitalization

Homebuilder Debt to Capitalization (Caterer Goodman)

LGIH's debt levels are acceptable, but others are better placed for this cycle.

For example Lennar and D.R. Horton are far better placed to pick up troubled smaller homebuilders. Every cycle will create opportunities to buy a troubled company on the cheap. Just this week, Australia's largest homebuilder, Metricon, is suffering a liquidity crisis due to fixed price contracts while materials costs exploded. There will be US versions of this later this cycle.

If we were running a home builder, we would be preparing the balance sheet now to buy smaller builders and their land banks for fire sale prices, as this cycle matures sometime in 2023 or 2024. Tremendous profits will be had.

Instead LGIH is buying land, and it's own stock, at peak cycle prices.

LGIH still has some room to act, but compared to the leaders it will be more limited in how much it can take advantage of these opportunities.

Mortgage rates are rising, increasing affordability problems

Both components of housing costs are surging: Home prices and mortgage rates. Home prices have jumped by record amounts.

Median Home Prices Jump

Median Home Prices Jump (NAR)

This rate of growth can't be sustainable.

It's worth pointing out that LGIH's average sales price of $341,000 is still well below the median US house price of almost $380,000.

Meanwhile, 30 year mortgage rates have also jumped past their recent 2018 peak. How high will they go? That depends on inflation and the Fed.

30 year mortgage rate
Data by YCharts

Like many, we worry that high inflation might stick in the 5-9% range for another year or two. A combination of problems with energy, food, supply chain shortages and tight labor markets make a potent combination.

Inflation might take quite a beating from the US Federal Reserve's interest rate stick before it succumbs. To us, a 2023 recession is an even money possibility based on present data.

Let's not get ahead though, right now there is an affordability crisis.

Housing Affordability Index

Housing Affordability Index (BofA Global Research)

Will the housing market be OK if 30 year mortgage rates top 6% and get close to 7%? Already housing affordability is close to lows around 2007-09. Still, it isn't all bad news, as fundamental demand for housing remains very strong.

Rising rents and LGIH's market position provide some protection

In case you haven't seen the headlines, the rental market is very tight. In fact the vacancy rate hasn't been this low since 1985.

US Rental Vacancy Rate

US Rental Vacancy Rate (Us Census Bureau)

This has resulted in rents jumping by record amounts in a year.

We believe rents are a better guide to fundamental housing demand because unlike owning, they lack the price surge due to rate decline dynamic.

US Rents Surge

US Rents Surge (RealPage)

Our guess is: with remote working now permissible, executives and white collar workers have moved closer to home (or another preferred place) yet have still retained their city house close to their office. We provide more evidence in our Lennar (LEN) article here.

With strong fundamental demand and rising rents, this will help a homebuilder that targets renters. Which builder? That's LGI Homes with it's more affordable entry level properties.

Homebuilder Average Sale Price

Homebuilder Average Sale Price (Caterer Goodman)

Of all major builders LGIH has the lowest average sale price. This is combination of two things. Mostly, it's the strategy of building entry level properties to sell to renters as a first home. It also reflects the dominance of the Central region for LGIH, with lower prices.

Valuation remains fair, but the risk has risen

Homebuilders usually trade in a tight range of 9-12 but the whole sector has sold off in recent quarters. A PE of 4-5 puts us firmly in value trap range. Given rising rates, that's probably fair and a return to earnings similar to 2019 levels could happen once the market slows.

Homebuilder Valuation Muliples

Homebuilder Valuation Multiples (Caterer Goodman)

This means the sector has already priced in a significant slowdown. These might be bargain prices if that is somehow avoided. But we struggle to pick LGIH over other builders. Lennar and D.R. Horton have similar, if not lower multiples, yet provide advantages of:

  • lower debt multiples, providing flexibility.
  • a dividend yield.
  • size.

Inflation and rising rate expectations should be respected for their ability to slow this housing boom to a near halt. Strong housing market fundamentals mean a crash is very unlikely. Yet an interest rate spike cannot be discounted.

In just the last couple of months forecasters have increased their rate forecasts significantly. February forecast is the dotted line with the jump to the higher hard line in May quite dramatic.

Rate Forecast Increase

Rate Forecasts Increase (Bank of England)

Inflation blame can be shared widely. Putin's invasion of Russia has caused chaos for energy and food prices. China's ongoing lockdowns have snarled supply chains more than most realize. Neither seem imminently fixable.

These have been the big changes on top of tight labor and rental markets. Higher rates than 2018-2019 means mortgage rates will correspondingly go well past 5% to 6% or more. That will bite, particularly if the economy cools.

Conclusion

So for us, LGIH is a hold.

This is a break from a few years ago when LGI Homes was one of our favorite homebuilders. A PE of 5 would usually have us keenly interested. We liked their market leading growth trajectory and unique model able to deliver strong margins and low prices. This is a company worth following.

The macro environment is mixed. Rising rents and LGIH's Texas dependence provide some protection. Due to this, this isn't a sell recommendation. However we can't escape the fact that rising rates and rising debt levels will limit LGI Home's options as the housing market slows.

Home builders like DHI and LEN are better prepared and are trading on similar or lower multiples and look better, if you are planning to buy a home builder.

Bottom-line: LGIH is a hold.

This article was written by

CGP Asset Management manages discretionary trading accounts for clients in a “Global Technology Growth” strategy. This strategy combines quantitative and qualitative elements with a global perspective. The parent company Caterer Goodman Partners was co-founded by Owen Caterer in 2011 as a financial advisory firm, but since 2017 has focused exclusively on discretionary trading accounts on Interactive Brokers.
Follow

Disclosure: I/we have no stock, option or similar derivative position in any of the companies mentioned, and no plans to initiate any such positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recommended For You

Comments

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.