2 Oil Stocks To Buy As Energy Prices Soar

Jun. 28, 2022 10:17 AM ETPipestone Energy Corp. (BKBEF), MGY, PIPE:CA17 Comments9 Likes


  • It is incredible... high-margin, growth-potent, under-followed energy stocks can still be found now that commodity prices sustain at high levels.
  • In this article, I highlight Magnolia Oil & Gas and Pipestone Energy as such high-quality gems that can be had at a large margin of safety.
  • Despite the recent panic-driven selloff, the energy industry is still in an early bull market, as recognized by Buffett. It is thus opportune time to load up on high-quality energy stocks.
  • Looking for more investing ideas like this one? Get them exclusively at The Natural Resources Hub. Learn More »
Oil Drilling Rigs

photosbyjim/iStock via Getty Images

As crude oil and natural gas prices soar, the changing risk-reward profiles necessitates a shift of portfolio composition towards high margin producers, because high margins mean not only richer cash flow from operations but also lower breakeven and stronger downside protection. The challenge, however, is to find high-margin producers that are under-followed and can still be bought at an adequate margin of safety.

The mini-crash of oil and gas prices since mid-June has triggered a 30% pullback in Magnolia and 40% correction in Pipestone. In light of this selloff, let's look at these two stocks again.

Magnolia Oil & Gas

High margins

In the 1Q2022, Magnolia production averaged 31,289 bbls/d, 137,532 Mcf/d and 17,624 bbls/d. It realized US$58.44/boe on the total production of 71,835 boe/d, thanks to its acreage being located close to infrastructure and downstream market in the Gulf Coast.

  • Since 2018, on average the company was able to sell crude oil at ~100% of WTI and natural gas at ~93% of Henry Hub.
  • Magnolia has no plan to hedge as a result of its extremely low debt, with long-term debt at $400 million and cash as of March 31 at $346 million.

Adding the proved developed reserve F&D cost averaging US$8.73/boe in the past three years and operating expenses as shown in Fig. 1, Magnolia's full-cycle cash cost came to ~US$20/boe.

Cash operating expenses of Magnolia Oil & Gas, shown with non-cash stock based compensation, all per boe of production. LOE, lease operating expenses; GT&P, gathering, transportation & processing; G&A, general & administrative expense.

Fig. 1. Cash operating expenses of Magnolia Oil & Gas, shown with non-cash stock based compensation, all per boe of production. LOE, lease operating expenses; GT&P, gathering, transportation & processing; G&A, general & administrative expense (Laurentian Research based on data from Seeking Alpha and Magnolia Oil & Gas)

Between superior price realization and low cash cost, Magnolia emerges as one of the highest-margin producers in the U.S. Its full-cycle cash netback was as high as US$38.64/boe in the 1Q2022.

Decent growth

From 1Q2018 to 1Q2022, Magnolia was able to grow production at a CAGR of 11.5% despite the unprecedented interruption by the pandemic (Fig. 2).

Daily average production of Magnolia Oil & Gas.

Fig. 2. Daily average production of Magnolia (Laurentian Research based on data gathered from Seeking Alpha and Magnolia Oil & Gas)

Magnolia limits its capital spending on well drilling and completion (or D&C) to 55% of annual Adjusted EBITDAX, which came to $298 million in the 1Q2022. It expects to deliver >10% organic production growth in 2022.

Integrating its realized price, all-in cash margins and growth, Magnolia generates US$42.50 profit for every boe of production.


I recently estimated Magnolia had an intrinsic value of US$25 per share, based on its dividend and share buyback policy under US$55/bo WTI and US$2.75/Mcf Henry Hub.

  • However, should the oil and gas prices sustain at the 1Q2022 level, Magnolia is worth a per-share intrinsic value of US$47-56.
  • As of June 24, 2022, Magnolia changed hands at US$21.21 per share, implying an upside of >120%.

Magnolia is valued at an EV/EBITDA multiple of 3.2X and a P/FCF multiple of 5.90X, low relative to what peers grab, suggesting the stock is still under-followed.

Pipestone Energy

High margins

Pipestone Energy averaged 33 bo/d, 7,963 bc/d, 94,346 Mcf/d and 3,861 bbl/d of non-condensate NGLs in the 1Q2022. It realized C$61.85/boe on the total production of 27,581 boe/d, thanks to condensate and crude oil accounting for 28.99% of the production mix.

  • The percentage of crude oil and especially condensate in total production is the main determinant of the price realized by Montney operators. Condensate even captures a premium over crude oil because there exists a strong demand for it from the Canadian oil sands producers, such as Suncor Energy (SU).

Pipestone was able to find and develop proved developed reserves at a F&D cost of C$10.37/boe. Its all-in cash costs came to C$22.05/boe in the 1Q2022. Going forward, Pipestone is expected to reduce unit cash cost substantially through production growth-driven economies of scale.

Between advantageous price realization and low F&D cost and operating costs, Pipestone is one of the highest-margin producers in the Montney play. Its full-cycle cash netback was as high as C$29.43/boe in the 1Q2022.

Rapid growth

Pipestone has an ambitious growth plan for the next three years (Fig. 3). It is poised to ramp up CapEx to C$225-C$235 million, grow production to 31,000-33,000 boe/d, up 30% year-over-year in 2022. By 2024, production is expected to reach 46,000-48,000 boe/d (Fig. 4).

The 2022-2024 corporate plan of Pipestone Energy

Fig. 3. The 2022-2024 corporate plan of Pipestone Energy (Pipestone Energy presentation)

Pipestone Energy production growth trajectory, actual and forecast

Fig. 4. Pipestone Energy production growth trajectory, actual and forecast (Pipestone Energy presentation)

Integrating its realized price, all-in cash margins and growth, Pipestone generates C$38.26 (or US$29.68) profit for every boe of production.


According to Seeking Alpha data, Pipestone Energy has a forward EV/EBITDA multiple of 2.68X, as compared with industry average of 5.84X. That Pipestone is deeply undervalued can also be seen from its P/FCF multiple of 4.42X for 2022 and its being valued at 62% of proven reserve NAV or 38% of proven and probable reserve NAV.

Pipestone only has C$204 million of net debt as of the end of 1Q2022, while it is projected to pull in free cash flow of C$155-C$185 million in 2022, C$260 million in 2023, and C$245 million in 2024 (Fig. 3).

Have energy prices peaked?

“Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful.” - Warren Buffett

The greatest risk of going long these two stocks lies in that the oil and gas prices may continue to drop. Have oil and gas prices peaked and are we on the brink of yet another lengthy bear market?

I'll let the eloquent Arjun Murti answer the question:

I disagree that we are closer to a long-term peak than a trough, however, when (1) reinvestment rates and capital spending are near trough levels, (2) there is limited spare capacity anywhere in the world, (3) a Top 3 oil and gas producer (Russia) is turning into a pariah state, and (4) current western world politicians and policy makers remain stuck in apocalyptic, Malthusian “climate only” ideology.

He went on to point out the danger of calling a top prematurely:

In the 2000s super-cycle, when oil first traded above $30/bbl after a period between $15-$22/bbl (nominal) in the 1990s, just about everyone prematurely called peak; history appears to be repeating, or at least rhyming.

The severe selloff of energy equity since mid-June seems to result from investor concerns over a potential recession. It is a panic-induced pullback despite no fundamental changes to the energy landscape. Warren Buffett clearly agrees with that characterization of the oil market condition, because Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A) just picked up an additional 9.55 million shares of Occidental Petroleum (OXY) from skittish investors, boosting its stake to 16.3%.

Therefore, it seems to be an opportune time to buy energy stocks, particularly high-quality yet undervalued names like Magnolia and Pipestone.

Investor takeaways

In spite of volatility, the energy industry condition and commodity supply-demand fundamentals are still characteristic of the early phase of a multi-year bull market.

Investors may take advantage of the recent selloff to load up on high-margin producers Magnolia Oil & Gas and Pipestone Energy, two under-followed North American producers boasting high margins and strong growth outlook.

The Natural Resources Hub is the one-stop solution for investors who want to profit from the unfolding commodity super-cycle. 

Join The Natural Resources Hub today to invest alongside Laurentian Research, who has a track record of uncovering hidden-gem commodity ideas with multi-bagger upside for subscribers. Click HERE for a free trial now.

This article was written by

Laurentian Research profile picture
The best energy and mining stock ideas with multibagger potential

As a natural resources industry expert with years of successful investing experience, I conduct in-depth research to generate alpha-rich, low-risk ideas for the member of The Natural Resources Hub (TNRH). I focus on identifying high-quality deep values in the natural resources sector and undervalued wide-moat businesses, an investment approach that has proven to be extremely rewarding over the years.

Some abridged samples of my writings are published here, while 4X as many unabridged articles are posted without delay at TNRH, a popular Seeking Alpha Marketplace service, where you also find:

(1) a stream of high-alpha actionable investment ideas,

(2) live portfolios for both capital appreciation and income generation,

(3) various tools to aid your investment decision making,

(4) trade alerts and multiple thematic weekly newsletters and

(5) a community of investors to bounce off ideas and share information with.

Sign up HERE today to benefit from Laurentian Research's in-depth research and the TNRH platform right away!

* * *

Disclosure: Besides myself, TNRH is fortunate enough to have multiple other contributing authors who post articles for and share their views with our thriving community. These authors include Silver Coast Research, ..., among others. I'd like to emphasize that the articles contributed by these authors are the product of their respective independent research and analysis.


Disclosure: I/we have a beneficial long position in the shares of BKBEF, MGY either through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recommended For You

Comments (17)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.