Carvana: Zombie Stock #1 - Could Go To $0 As Fed Raises Rates

Jun. 29, 2022 2:39 PM ETCarvana Co. (CVNA)PTON, SQSP, FRPT, KMX, AN25 Comments11 Likes

Summary

  • Time is running out for cash-burning companies kept afloat with easy/cheap access to capital.
  • This report features Carvana, a zombie company with a high risk of seeing its stock go to $0/share.
  • Even if the company’s FCF burn slows to its three-year average, recently raised additional capital would keep the business afloat for just six months.
  • Looking for more investing ideas like this one? Get them exclusively at Value Investing 2.0 . Learn More »

Used Car Seller Carvana Lays Off Over 10 Percent Of Workforce

Joe Raedle/Getty Images News

Time is running out for cash-burning companies kept afloat with easy/cheap access to capital. These “zombie” companies are at risk of going bankrupt if they cannot raise more debt or equity, which is not as easy as it used to be.

As the Fed raises interest rates and ends quantitative easing, access to cheap capital is drying up quickly. At the same time, many companies face declining margins and may be forced to default on interest payments without the possibility of refinancing. As these zombie companies run out of the cash needed to stay afloat, risk premiums will rise across the market, which could further squeeze liquidity and create an escalating series of corporate defaults.

This report features Carvana Co. (NYSE:CVNA), a zombie company with a high risk of seeing its stock go to $0/share.

Zombie Companies with Little Cash Are Risky

Companies with heavy cash burn and little cash on hand are risky in today’s market. Being forced to raise capital in this environment, even if the company is ultimately successful, is not good for existing shareholders.

Figure 1 shows the zombie companies most likely to run out of cash first, based on free cash flow (FCF) burn and cash on the balance sheet over the trailing-twelve-months (TTM). Each company in Figure 1 has:

  • Negative interest coverage ratio (EBIT/Interest expense)
  • Negative FCF over the TTM
  • Less than 24 months before it needs more capital to subsidize the TTM FCF burn rate
  • Been a Danger Zone pick

Not surprisingly, the companies that are most at risk of seeing their stock price go to $0 are the ones with a poor underlying business model, which was overlooked by investors during the 2020-2021 meme stock-driven market frenzy. Companies such as Carvana, Freshpet (FRPT), Peloton (PTON), and Squarespace (SQSP) have less than six months of cash on their balance sheets based on their FCF burn over the past twelve months. These stocks have a real risk of going to zero.

Figure 1: Danger Zone Stocks with Less than Two Year’s Worth of Cash on Hand: as of 1Q22

Zombie Companies

Zombie Companies (New Constructs, LLC)

Sources: New Constructs, LLC and company filings. To calculate “Months Before Bankruptcy” we divided the TTM FCF burn by 12, which equals monthly cash burn. We then divide Cash and Equivalents on the balance sheet through 1Q22 by monthly cash burn.

And Overvalued Zombie Stocks Are the Riskiest

Stock valuations that embed high expectations for future profit growth add more risk to owning shares of zombie companies with just a few months’ worth of cash left. For the riskiest zombie companies, not only does the stock price not reflect the short-term distress facing the company, but it also reflects unrealistically optimistic assumptions about the long-term profitability of the company. With these stocks, overvaluation risk is stacked on top of short-term cash flow risk.

Below, we’ll take a closer look at Carvana and detail the company’s cash burn and how much further its stock price could fall.

Carvana

We put Carvana (CVNA) in the Danger Zone in August 2020, and the stock has outperformed the S&P 500 as a short by 95% since then. Even after falling 93% from its 52-week high, 89% YTD, and 67% from our report in April 2022, we think the stock has much more downside.

Carvana has failed to generate positive free cash flow in any year since going public in 2017. Since 2016, Carvana has burned through $8.3 billion in FCF, per Figure 2. Indeed, the cash bonfire at Carvana is roaring as the company burned through $4.0 billion in FCF over the TTM ended 1Q22. With just $247 million in cash and cash equivalents on the balance sheet at the end of 1Q22, Carvana’s cash balance could only have sustained its cash burn for less than one month after 1Q22.

Not surprisingly, Carvana issued $3.3 billion in senior unsecured notes in April 2022, which bear an interest rate of 10.25%. The interest rate on the debt is substantially higher than the 4.875% rate on senior unsecured notes issued in August 2021. However, most of this capital is already accounted for, as Carvana is using the proceeds to fund the $2.2 billion acquisition of ADESA’s U.S. auction business.

Assuming Carvana pockets the $1.1 billion of cash remaining after the ADESA deal, the company has just three additional months of cash left, based on its TTM cash burn rate. Even if the company’s FCF burn slows to its three-year average, the additional capital would keep the business afloat for just six months. Despite raising capital just three months ago, Carvana will likely need to raise more before the end of this year.

Figure 2: Carvana’s Cumulative Free Cash Flow Since 2016

CVNA Cumulative Cash Burn

CVNA Cumulative Cash Burn (New Constructs, LLC)

Sources: New Constructs, LLC and company filings.

Valuation Implies Carvana Generates More Sales than the Two Largest Used Car Dealers

We use our reverse discounted cash flow model to analyze the future cash flow expectations baked into Carvana’s current valuation. Despite fierce competition and negative profit margins when used-car prices have skyrocketed, Carvana’s stock is priced as if the business will grow revenues to higher levels than of CarMax (KMX) and AutoNation (AN), a feat that is highly unlikely to materialize.

To justify its current price of $25/share, our model shows that Carvana would have to:

  • immediately improve its NOPAT margin to 3%, (above 2021 NOPAT margin of -1% but below CarMax at 4%) and
  • grow revenue by 15% compounded annually (1.6x projected industry growth through 2027) for the next seven years.

In this scenario, Carvana’s revenue in 2028 would reach $34.1 billion, which is 106% of the TTM revenue of CarMax and 128% of the TTM revenue of AutoNation, the two largest used-car dealers by revenue.

This scenario implies the firm would sell ~1.2 million retail and wholesale vehicles in 2028[1] versus just over 632,000 sold over the last twelve months. Such high sales would be three-fourths the vehicles sold over the TTM by the largest U.S. used car retailer, CarMax. In a mature market, which used cars surely are, that much growth requires taking significant market share away from formidable competitors.

This scenario also implies Carvana grows NOPAT from -$446 million over the TTM to $1.0 billion in 2028, which is 82% of CarMax’s fiscal 2022 NOPAT.

80% Downside If Carvana Grows at Industry Rates

Below, we review an additional DCF scenario to highlight the downside risk even if Carvana’s revenue grows at the same pace as the used-car industry and margins rise to half that of CarMax.

If we assume Carvana’s:

  • NOPAT margin improves to 2% (below 2021 NOPAT margin of -1%, TTM margin of -3%, and half of CarMax’s TTM margin),
  • revenue grows at consensus rates in 2022 and 2023, and
  • revenue grows by 9% a year from 2024 through 2028 (equal to projected industry growth rate through 2027), then

the stock would be worth just $5/share today – an 80% downside to the current price.

In this scenario, the firm grows revenue to $32.1 billion in 2028, and assuming Carvana generates ~$28 thousand per vehicle sold (using same assumptions as prior scenarios), the firm would sell 1.1 million vehicles in 2028, a near doubling from TTM levels and 69% of the vehicles sold by CarMax in its fiscal 2022.

This scenario implies Carvana grows NOPAT from -$446 million over the TTM to $657 million in 2028, which is 53% of CarMax’s fiscal 2022 NOPAT.

Figure 3 compares Carvana’s implied future NOPAT in these scenarios to its historical NOPAT. We also include the TTM NOPAT for CarMax for reference.

Figure 3: Carvana’s Historical and Implied NOPAT: DCF Valuation Scenarios

CVNA DCF Implied NOPAT

CVNA DCF Implied NOPAT (New Constructs, LLC)

Sources: New Constructs, LLC and company filings.

Each of the above scenarios also assumes Carvana grows revenue, NOPAT, and FCF without increasing working capital or fixed assets. This assumption is highly unlikely but allows us to create best-case scenarios that demonstrate the expectations embedded in the current valuation. For reference, Carvana’s invested capital grew 86% compounded annually from 2015 through 2021. If we assume Carvana’s invested capital increases at a similar rate in the DCF scenarios above, the downside risk is even larger.

This article originally published on June 23, 2022.

Disclosure: David Trainer, Kyle Guske II, and Matt Shuler receive no compensation to write about any specific stock, style, or theme.

[1] Calculated by taking the implied revenue divided by the implied revenue per vehicle. Over the TTM, Carvana generated a total of $14.1 billion in revenue and sold 632 thousand combined retail and wholesale vehicles, which equates to ~$22.2 thousand in revenue per unit sold. Assuming inflation of 3.5% per year, revenue per unit sold in 2028 would be ~$28.3 thousand.

Get our long and short/warning ideas. Access to top accounting and finance experts.

Deliverables:

1. Daily – long & short idea updates as necessary, forensic accounting insights, chat features

2. Weekly - exclusive access to top-ranked long & short ideas

3. Monthly - 40 large, 40 small cap ideas from the Most Attractive & Most Dangerous Stocks Model Portfolios

4. Quarterly – Best & Worst ETFs and Mutual Funds in each Sector & Style

See the difference that real diligence makes.

This article was written by

David Trainer profile picture
15.83K Followers
Best fundamental research: most rigorous long & short ideas
New Constructs is an independent research technology firm that provides unrivaled insights into the fundamentals and valuation of private & public businesses. Combining human expertise with machine learning and NLP, the firm shines light into the dark corners (e.g. footnotes) of millions of financial filings and provides superior investment research. The firm's Robo-Analyst technology is the first-ever vertically integrated investment research platform: performing data collection, financial modeling and assigning investment ratings to over 10,000 securities - automatically. This new technology is research automation at its best according to:


   1. Harvard Business School & MIT Sloan prove our fundamental data is superior.


   2. Ernst & Young proves the superiority of our financial analytics over Capital IQ & Bloomberg.


   3. Indiana Kelly School of Business proves our stock ratings outperform human analysts.



If these prestigious institutions trust us so much that they decided to publish official papers to prove the superiority of our research, then you can safely trust us, too.

New Constructs' clients include investors of all types from quant funds like GSAM who subscribe to proprietary data feeds, advisors and individuals who subscribe to our investment research directly through our website.


David is CEO of New Constructs (www.newconstructs.com). David is a distinguished investment strategist and corporate finance expert. He was a 5-yr member of FASB's Investors Advisory Committee. He is author of the Chapter “Modern Tools for Valuation” in The Valuation Handbook (Wiley Finance 2010). 


Follow

Disclosure: I/we have no stock, option or similar derivative position in any of the companies mentioned, and no plans to initiate any such positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recommended For You

Comments (25)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.