BCE Inc.: Get Out Now

Jordan Sauer profile picture
Jordan Sauer
1.93K Followers

Summary

  • BCE is seen as a stable dividend stock. But, its dividend is not supported by cash flow, it's supported by debt and share dilution.
  • With many of its businesses in secular decline, BCE is swimming upstream. Technology is changing the industry.
  • At a forward PE of 19x, the valuation is in line with that of Google. We see a lost decade ahead for BCE.

Butler holding hand bell on grey background, closeupu

Liudmila Chernetska/iStock via Getty Images

The Thesis

Many tout BCE (NYSE:BCE) for its oligopoly position in Canadian telecom, along with its enormous dividends. But, if you look under the surface, you'll find deteriorating trends. We believe investors should revisit their thesis with an open mind, and we'll outline why. In the decade ahead, we project returns of 1% per annum.

Secular Decline

BCE makes its money from three big segments: Wireless, wireline, and media:

Bell's Operating Revenue By Segment

Bell's Operating Revenue By Segment (Statista)

BCE's involved in a number of businesses that are already in or near secular decline, such as land-line telephone, cable TV, and radio. As you can see above, this is affecting the company's growth. Meanwhile, SpaceX's Starlink is aiming to provide constellation satellite internet across the globe and has already expanded into Canada.

Once a near monopoly, BCE's power is dwindling as Smart TVs change the landscape. The company has several media assets that now have to compete on third-party platforms like Roku (ROKU) and Apple TV (AAPL).

Bell's Media Assets

Bell's Media Assets (Annual Report)

Although BCE owns great television assets, there's no question the company was better positioned in the early 2000s. Since then, growth has stagnated and even declined in some segments. Even assets like Crave and iHeart Radio are subject to immense competition from applications like Netflix (NFLX), Spotify (SPOT), YouTube (GOOG) (GOOGL), Disney+ (DIS), and Amazon Prime Video (AMZN).

Then you have Meta's (META) Messenger and WhatsApp, allowing us to receive instant text, calls, and video anywhere there's an internet connection.

To remain relevant, many telecom companies are now pushing 5G technology. But is 5G internet really worth it? BCE is investing billions of dollars into this infrastructure, which is coming out of investors' pockets. Nobody knows how long 5G will be relevant for.

A Look Under The Surface

Yes, BCE pays a huge dividend and has done so consistently. But, under the surface, there are serious issues.

The Dividend Cut

BCE is diluting shareholders, perhaps because it cannot afford to stay competitive and to pay an enormous dividend at the same time. Like we said, 5G is expensive. Over the past 12 months, BCE paid out 378% of its free cash flow and 112% of its net income as a dividend. It goes without saying that this is extremely unhealthy and comes with enormous risk of a dividend cut.

Diluting Shareholders

BCE's Shares Outstanding:

BCE: Shares Outstanding
Data by YCharts

Swimming In Debt

Meanwhile, BCE has racked up $24 billion USD of long-term debt and capital leases, which is 10x its net income. The company constantly carries a negative working capital. If BCE spirals into higher and higher debt as its core businesses decline, things could get ugly, especially as interest rates climb higher.

The Valuation

Bell's EPS

Bell's EPS (Macrotrends)

BCE's earnings have been in decline for a decade now, but the stock has been propped up on the back of low interest rates and limited investment alternatives for Canadians. At 3x book, with a forward P/E of 19, the stock is by no means cheap. In fact, it trades at a similar forward P/E to Google, a far superior business in nearly every regard.

All figures are in USD:

BCE is projected to earn $2.92 per share in 2024, barely enough to cover its dividend of $2.81 per share. We think a dividend cut is likely. BCE has said it wants a payout ratio of 65 to 75 percent of free cash flow. A $2.00 dividend is our base-case scenario, implying a 4% yield.

BCE's earnings will fluctuate over time, but its pricing power is likely to be offset by secular decline in its other businesses. The company has tremendous debt and little capital to defend against technological change.

Our 2032 price target is $33 per share, implying a return of 1% per annum with dividends reinvested.

  • We believe BCE's earnings will plateau around $3.00 per share as it struggles to replace declining revenue streams and pay down debt. We've applied a terminal multiple of 11, which may seem low, but is still a premium to where Verizon (VZ) and AT&T (T) trade at the moment.

Risks To The Thesis

BCE has pricing power in its wireless service, as Canadians pay some of the highest mobile plan prices in the world. If Rogers (RCI) can successfully merge with Shaw (SJR), wireline consumers could get squeezed. 5G has not yet matured and could improve BCE's financial position. If the oligopoly can weather the technological change that comes with Smart TVs, streaming, and Starlink's satellite internet, it will benefit from inflation and pricing power. Any long-term growth would be a boon for BCE's terminal multiple.

Conclusion

Given the financial and technological deterioration outlined above, we believe our "get out now" recommendation is warranted. Even with dividends reinvested, BCE could face a lost decade. The world is constantly changing. With competition from Roku, Apple, Netflix, Spotify, YouTube, Disney, Amazon, Meta, and SpaceX's Starlink, BCE's once powerful position is dwindling. If you look beyond the dividend, you'll find enormous debts and share dilution. We hope this contrary analysis will be beneficial in navigating an uncertain future.

For investors looking to keep a telecom holding, we recommend Verizon. For more on this, check out my article:

This article was written by

Jordan Sauer profile picture
1.93K Followers
A natural contrarian, business student, and a value investor. I seek opportunities in the market that present outsized returns. I am constantly analyzing financial statements, reading books, stress-testing my opinions, and studying the principles of great investors.

Disclosure: I/we have a beneficial long position in the shares of META either through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Additional disclosure: This article includes base-case scenario estimates, using known facts and economic projections. The future is uncertain, and investors must draw their own conclusions.

Recommended For You

Comments (62)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.