Olympic Steel: Deep Value Alert, Trading Below Liquidation Value

Aug. 05, 2022 5:51 PM ETOlympic Steel, Inc. (ZEUS)STLD, TX, X, CLF6 Comments6 Likes
ESP equity research profile picture
ESP equity research


  • Olympic Steel is currently trading at 10% below it's liquidation value, and 30% below it's book value.
  • Over the past 4 quarters, Olympic Steel, Inc. has earned over $13 per share, for a P/E ratio just over 2.
  • Olympic Steel has significantly diversified its business both products and geographically.
  • Olympic Steel's CEO for the first time has made a bold statement: "consistently produce earnings in all market cycles"

Roll of galvanized steel sheet at metalworking factory

Vladimir Zapletin

I had Olympic Steel, Inc. (NASDAQ:ZEUS) as one of my top picks for 2021. You can read that article here and learn more about its business. In this article, I had 3 main dynamics that would lead to increased profits for Olympic Steel and the entire steel industry:

  • End of COVID demand - economy reopening
  • New administration's push for more investment in infrastructure
  • Growing demand for steel from the growing electric vehicle movement.

We are still seeing these tailwinds for the steel industry today. Our economy has opened up, we are at or close to full employment, the revised Build Back Better act is soon to be passed, and the continued rollout of the $1 trillion infrastructure bill.

But, with the U.S. economy reopened, and supply chain issues remaining, we have seen very high levels of inflation. This has led the federal reserve to aggressively raise borrowing rates. So even with all this demand, we have seen GDP fall for 2 consecutive quarters.

The current state of the steel industry

As my last steel article showed, steel prices were rising fast in 2021, hitting a peak of around $1,500 a ton for hot rolled coil - HRC. This created an excellent environment for the steel industry. Over the past few months, prices have declined rapidly - down to below $900. We have seen similar declines in many other commodities such as copper, lumber, fertilizer, etc...

For the steel industry, $800-900 for HRC is still a very profitable level. All the steel firms we track are guiding to lower earnings and EBITDA for the 3rd quarter due to this decline in steel prices. But due to this decline in steel price, the stock stocks have been hammered - many trading with trailing and forward P/E's below 4.

With this set-up, why Olympic Steel? One could argue many steel firms are "deep value" alerts: United States Steel (X), Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF), Ternium (TX), etc... In this article, I will make this fairly simple. Olympic Steel is the top pick because of the number one rule in value investing:

Principle #1: Always Invest with a Margin of Safety - Benjamin Graham

Benjamin Graham was an investor and is generally considered the father of security analysis and value investing. Margin of safety is the principle of buying a security at a significant discount to its intrinsic value, which is thought to not only provide high-return opportunities but also minimize the downside risk of an investment. In simple terms, Graham's goal was to buy assets worth $1 for 50 cents. He did this very, very well.

One metric I look at for this margin of safety concept is "liquidation Value." My formula for this metric is as follows:

(cash and cash equivalents + accounts receivables + inventory) - (accounts payables + debt).

Or more basically stated - Current assets - Current liabilities and debts.

Olympic Steels 2nd quarter results

There is no other way to describe the Q2 numbers - blowout! The company achieved record quarterly sales and delivered the second-most-profitable quarter in its history. Net income for the second quarter totaled $37.6 million, or $3.26 per diluted share, a 26% increase from a year ago. The company reported all-time record quarterly sales of $709 million in the second quarter of 2022, a 28% increase from the prior year.

As shown in my last Olympic Steel article, they have made several key acquisitions over the past few years to diversify away from steel prices like HRC. Currently, they are around 50% levered to HRC prices down significantly from 5 years ago. With this new level of diversification, the company raised its quarterly dividend from $0.02 per share to $0.09 per share in March 2022.

Here is a quick look at Olympic Steel product and end-user market diversification:

From company website

Olympic Steel

From company website

Olympic Steel

For us, the most positive comment from CEO Richard Marabito was this:

While metal pricing is declining during the third quarter, we remain optimistic regarding underlying demand and our ability to consistently produce earnings in all market cycles,” Marabito concluded.

For such a cyclical industry, and Olympic Steel is such a small firm, this is a bold statement. Olympic Steel earned over $13 a share for the past 12 months - P/E of about 2. Yes, we all know this is partly the "cyclical" high point, but now Olympic Steel is stating that they will be profitable at "cyclical" low points.

Just looking forward, and with their dividend now around 40 cents per share, we could estimate a cycle low 12-month period to have EPS of $1-2. So full-cycle - high and lows would see a P/E of around 4 - this is really Deep Value...

Olympic Steel's Liquidation Value

This very hypothetic metric could be described this way: what if another entity were to buy Olympic Steel - let's say another steel firm or a private equity firm, and decided to just sell out its assets and cash out? So in 6-9 months run down the inventory, collect all receivables, and pay all accounts payables, and debts. Here is a table of my liquidation values for the past 12 months:

Sep-21 Dec-21 Mar-22 Jun-22
Cash $15 $10 $8 $8
Accounts Receivable $303 $285 $313 $321
Inventory $418 $485 $475 $511
Total current value $736 $779 $797 $840
Accounts payable $160 $149 $163 $182
Asset-backed loan - ABL $302 $330 $312 $288
Total current liabilities $462 $479 $475 $470
Current liquidation value $275 $300 $322 $370
Liquidation value per share $24.97 $27.31 $29.23 $33.65

So one can see that the current value is about $34 a share - 10% above its closing price on August 4th. And as we can see this is a 35% increase from September 2021. Also of note Olympic Steel is trading at a 30% discount to its net asset value. And management has stated that this value will continue to rise. This is a Benjamin Graham deep value special alert.

Investor takeaways

Olympic Steel has diversified its business model, producing record levels of revenues and earnings, and has the ability to perform well even in economic downturns and low steel prices. With a current market cap below $350 million - this micro-cap could become an acquisition target as well.

We find Olympic Steel to be a strong buy below its net asset value of about $40 a share.

The risks for investors here are small in our opinion since this firm is currently trading below its liquidation value, but risks still remain:

  • The Federal Reserve raising rates too far, sending the U.S. economy into a deep, deep recession.
  • Individual stock risk - accounting issues, lawsuits, etc...

We are also very positive about other steel firms: US Steel, Ternium, and Steel Dynamics (STLD).

This article was written by

ESP equity research profile picture
ESP is a buy-side equity research firm that manages an options income equity fund. We specialize in the following industries: Renewable Energy, Energy, Commodities, Electrification of Everything(EoE), EV's, Software, and the New Energy Economy.We also offer energy consulting services to businesses, utilities, and municipalities enabling the transition to the 100% renewable economy. ESP also provides Electric macro grid and microgrid modeling services. You can see our current top stock picks, and former trades dating back from 2008 on our Motley Fools CAPS page. Since 2008 our accuracy record is over 80% beating the S&P 500 index.

Disclosure: I/we have a beneficial long position in the shares of ZEUS either through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recommended For You

Comments (6)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.