Fate Therapeutics: Yes For Speculators, No For Defensive Investors

Aug. 30, 2022 3:36 PM ETFate Therapeutics, Inc. (FATE)


  • Fate Therapeutics has potential inflection points stemming from clinical trial and regulatory momentum in the next 6-12 months.
  • For those taking speculative positions within healthcare, this could present with potential upsides post-event(s).
  • Those investors looking for a defensive overlay within healthcare might find weakness in FATE's measures of corporate value.
  • With these points in mind, we rate FATE a hold with a $21 per share valuation.

Dendrimers in nanobiomedicine with nanodrugs cargo

Love Employee/iStock via Getty Images

Investment summary

There are selective opportunities located within the healthcare universe for investors taking both speculative and defensive positions. In either sense, factor rotations in H2 FY22 corroborate that value remains a thematic favorite for investors, adding a layer of resiliency to portfolios. Measures examining corporate value are therefore of upmost importance for equity investors looking ahead, in order to decipher the quality of earnings and business model one is allocating to.

With this in mind, we examined Fate Therapeutics, Inc. (NASDAQ:FATE) and found that it offers potential upsides from clinical trial and regulatory momentum over the next 6-12 months. For those on the speculative side, this is ideal. However, we also noted that for those seeking a defensive beta name in healthcare, FATE might not be the best choice, due to lack of profitability and unsupportive valuations from forward earnings. With opportunity costs front of mind, but also acknowledging the strengths in FATE's wider offering, we rate FATE a hold with a price target of $21.

Exhibit 1. FATE 6-month price action


Data: Refinitiv Eikon

Q2 earnings indicative of regulatory, fundamental momentum

Fundamental momentum is creeping up alongside regulatory momentum for FATE. Despite this, its earnings do need some cleaning up to reflect a more accurate snapshot. Revenue obtained via collaborations with Janssen and Ono Pharmaceutical (OTCPK:OPHLY) rose to $18.5 million in Q2 FY22, a 38% growth YoY. Meanwhile, the company saw a ~67% YoY headwind at the G&A line with expenditures increasing to $20.4 million. However, breaking down the increase in G&A, ~34% or $6.9 million ($0.07/share) was attributed to stock based compensation ("SBC"), up $4.3 million from this time last year. Operating expenses were also comprised of $81.3 million in R&D spend, that we argue should be capitalized and treated as an investment on the balance sheet [discussed later]. All in, SBC comprised $20.5 million of the $101.6 million in operating spend for the quarter.

On the regulatory front, FATE achieved its first clinical milestone in its CAR T-cell product candidate, FT819. This is under an amended license agreement with Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Centre ("MSK"). The first milestone payment to MSK was activated following this milestone. This is important as there could be an additional 2 milestone payments obliged to MSK that are based on trading volumes of the company's stock in ranges of $100-$150/share. Changes in the fair value of these instruments is booked as income or expenditure by FATE and is therefore worth keeping an eye on from period to period and make necessary adjustments if necessary.

Exhibit 2. FT819 descriptive overview


Data: Fate Therapeutics Website

Meanwhile, the Phase 1 trial of FATE's FY596 in combination with rituximab exhibited favorable safety data in both the single dose and dual-dose cohorts. Safety data held up well up to 900 million cells per dose, and the higher-dose regime could well be the protocol looking ahead, by estimate. From here FATA will continue to evaluate dosages for maximal therapeutic effect, with the next moves being a 3-dose cohort at a dose of 1.8 billion cells. We are intrigued to observe the outcome of the increased cellular load, particularly as the clinical protocol permits further dose escalation

In terms of regulatory catalysts, investors should keep an eye out for the company's FT516 RMAT Type-B multidisciplinary meeting with the FDA this coming quarter. From here we'll have better understanding on the registrational pathways for the off-shelf programs against refractory aggressive B-cell lymphoma. Patients will include those whose disease is refractory or relapsed after previous treatment from other CD19 targeted CAR T-cell therapies.

Reconciliations for accurate valuation

We've identified a number of adjustments that need to be made in order to accurately value FATE, in order to understand exactly what it is we're buying. Firstly, R&D expenditure came in at $81 million for the quarter, up from $48 million YoY. We argue that R&D expenditure should be capitalized and amortized as an intangible asset, as it is an investment set to create future economic value. This has implications to earnings and investment for the company. However, we also found we can't capitalize FATE's entire R&D spend.

Notably, the $33 million YoY increase in R&D stemmed from:

  • $4.9 million increase in employee SBC expense to $13.57 million
  • $9 million increase in spend to third-party professional consultants
  • $8.6 million increase in expenditures for laboratory materials and supplies relating to the manufacture of product candidates and conduct of research activities.

Therefore, we can only advocate to capitalize $67.4 million of R&D as an investment, seeing as SBC is an expense in our eyes. This has implications for both earnings and valuation, as discussed below. In addition, the company's drug product manufacturing facility in California has now opened with engineering runs underway. This is a tangible source of value that will supply drug products for companies conducting pivotal trials. In all, the company has $580 million in tangible book value with this included.

Exhibit 3.


Data & Image: HB Insights


Being a clinical stage biopharma company, valuation ideally comprises a number of factors to obtain a corporate value for the company. However, we aren't confident on the predictability of estimating the prospective value of FATE's pipeline or working in terms of what's 'possible'. Instead, what's real and 'probable' are better terms to work by. With that, we observe corporate valuation in terms of earnings and investment; what's real and what's expected. We record this in shorthand with multiples of book value and earnings estimates. Instead, we are focusing on what we'd be buying today in FATE.

Keeping this mantra in mind, with respect to the investment pile, we note shares appear to be richly priced after reorganizing for adjustments as in Exhibit 3. As seen in the Exhibit below, shares are priced at ~4.6x book value, and 3.8x enterprise value ("EV") to book value. Post-adjustment, at these multiples, we are paying an implied value of $25-$30.71 [prior, shares looked to be fairly priced]. The question is if this presents as compelling value or if we'd be overpaying. Given its lack of profitability, return on equity measures are negligible for the company.

Exhibit 4. Post-adjustment valuations look pricey


Data: HB Insights Estimates. Image: HB Insights

In this vein, we have to project the future cash flows on offer for the company. We see this best represented at the top line for FATE in its collaborative revenue. As seen in Exhibit 5, the valuation model prescribed delivers a valuation of just $21 for the company, suggesting we'd be overpaying at current prices. Investors are asked to pay ~$25-$30 in implied value to receive a potential downside of 30% at the upper end.

Exhibit 5. Fair value distribution values FATE with a value gap to the downside

Lack of profitability and lack of predictability in estimating the company's future cash flows are key factors in the valuation debate


Data: HB Insights Estimates. Image: HB Insights

With the culmination of these factors in mind - valuations in particular - we rate FATE a hold and look forward to observing potential inflection points from the clinical trial and regulatory momentum listed above.

This article was written by

Buy side equity portfolio strategists serving mandates throughout EU/US/APAC. Helping you position your portfolios for the future is our top priority. We offer unique insights via our holding strategies that rest at the long end of the equity curve with minimal drag/drawdown. Shoot us a message to discuss trade ides or talk portfolio construction. Disclaimer:The opinions expressed in all articles do not constitute as investment advice. Please remember to conduct your own due diligence. Hummingbird Investment Group Ltd ("The Company") does not provide investment counsel to non-cliental. Additionally, all investing comes with inherent risks, and there are a plethora risks investors must consider before any investment decision. Past returns are not indicative of future performance, and should not be relied upon as an indicator for investment outcomes. Therefore, the opinions expressed in any and all analyses conducted on Seeking Alpha from The Company, does not constitute as advice, guidance, recommendation or counsel, and therefore should not be received as so. The Company's opinions and commentary are subject to unforeseen market forces which may result in outcomes different from postulates within quantitative modelling. In any case or situation, neither The Company, or its acquired interests, accepts any liability for loss of capital or liquidity erosion, based on an individual's own investment reasoning.

Disclosure: I/we have no stock, option or similar derivative position in any of the companies mentioned, and no plans to initiate any such positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Recommended For You


To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.