Rates Spark: Bank Of England Vs. The Market

Summary

  • UK rates haven’t had a chance to fully digest the Bank of England’s statement yesterday.
  • We think hike expectations will persist, but there are other areas where the BoE and Treasury can restore confidence.
  • Tough to stand in the way of higher US rates, even with the market very biased that way.

British one pound coins on a financial graph background

Zedelle/iStock via Getty Images

UK gilts: All crises lead to higher yields

From inflation to fiscal sustainability worries, and from fiscal sustainability worries to a loss of confidence in sterling and sterling-denominated assets, the past few months have been a bruising one for gilts. Macro concerns are of course legitimate, but we feel the scale of the sell-off in UK rates has a clear element of market disfunction. Liquidity in gilts has been deteriorating all year, and the Bank of England (BoE) is adding to the already fraught environment by reducing the size of its bond portfolio. Stopping this policy, also known as quantitative tightening (QT), is one of the low-hanging fruits for UK policymakers to restore confidence in the country’s economic management.

This is a necessary but by no means a sufficient condition, however. Gilts have suffered from the perception that the Treasury (through more generous spending and tax cuts) and the BoE (trying to offset the inflationary implications) are working at cross-purposes. The result has been a perfect storm: more gilts issuance and more BoE hikes. Any sign of better cooperation (for instance, by government spending cuts or a windfall tax on energy companies) would also go a long way to shore up confidence in gilts and the pound. As often however, it will take time for investors to regain their appetite for gilts after the recent volatility. At first glance, the BoE’s struggle to calm market expectations of an inter-meeting emergency hike is another example of the market’s nervousness.

10Y gilts have crossed well above our 4% yield and 200bp spread over Bund forecasts. Given that some of this sell-off is explained by hopes of a BoE intervention that might not materialise, we would refrain from moving our forecast ever higher.

10-year gilt yields, 10-year Bund yields, Gilt-Bund spread - Gilts have moved through our 4 percent yield and 200bp spread to Bund forecasts

Gilts Have Moved Through Our 4% Yield And 200bp Spread To Bund Forecasts (Refinitiv, ING)

Italy: The carrot and sticks do their job, for now

Italy’s political developments played second fiddle to the exceptional volatility in sterling markets, but the election of a potentially stable right-wing coalition is no less momentous. Markets took a sanguine view, judging from the solid price action in Italian bonds into the election, but Italian bonds gave it all back yesterday. We tend to agree that, in the short run, risks of fiscal divergence are limited. Potential good news could be the nomination of a market-friendly Finance Minister (e.g., out of the European Central Bank or Banca d’Italia) and no wholesale change to the 2023 budget.

At its core, the market’s relaxed approach is a reflection of the trust in the EU’s carrot (almost €200bn in grants and loans from NGeu) and stick (risk of a bond market crisis if the ECB withdraws its support). Longer term, markets are ill-equipped to assess the risk of Italy diverging from EU fiscal guidance from a party that has never been in power. All this calls for caution, especially given the backdrop of hawkish central banks. The prospect of the ECB reducing its bond portfolio, in particular, could be another delay of selling pressure on Italian bonds and take 10Y spreads to Germany above the 250bp.

10-year Italian bond-Bund spread; EUR swaptions 3-month, 10-year volatility - Even if they give Meloni the benefit of the doubt, Italian spreads are pushed wider by rates volatility

Even if they give Meloni the benefit of the doubt, Italian spreads are pushed wider by rates volatility (Refinitiv, ING)

US market rates still on wider crisis watch

The US 10yr yield is powering towards 4%, and the Treasury / Bund spread has re-widened, but there is not a huge sense that the bond market rout is being driven by the Treasuries. It's more of a synchronized process, but with differentiating drivers (two of which are summarized above). The common denominator is interest rate risk, and the net power play is the US by virtue of implied capital flows coming from the movement in FX rates (dollar strength). These, in fact, mute the magnitude of rises in US market rates.

That said, bond players maintain a preference to short the market. The repo market is littered with bond trading on special, reflecting an ongoing excess of liquidity over collateral, but also now two other items: (1) A market preference to short the market (where bonds need to be borrowed), and (2) A desire to fly to the safety of the Fed’s reverse repo facility where 3.05% is on offer with no capital at risk. SOFR is finding is tough to even get up to 3% (latest 2.99%), which is illustrative of the same.

And the system is holding up so far. Financial commercial paper is holding in at single digits over the risk-free rate. We can’t see this continuing; expect a larger concession to build for bank funding ultimately. But for now, all is good; which is also a positive signal for contemporaneous liquidity circumstances. Wider liquidity has become worse in the past number of days though. Price discovery is tough in consequence, causing prices to run away from business, manifesting in wider bid/offer spread at times.

Today’s events and market view

The EU’s economic calendar consists only of M3 money growth for August. Instead, the focus is likely to be on the Netherlands launching a new 30Y benchmark, followed by Italy selling 2Y and 10Y inflation-linked bonds, and by Germany selling 5Y debt via auction.

Naturally, central bankers will be closely watched. None will be as much as Huw Pill, the BoE’s chief economist after gyrations in the gilt and FX markets. Other names on today’s roster are Mario Centeno, Francois Villeroy, Christine Lagarde, Luis de Guindos, and Fabio Panetta of the ECB, and Charles Evans, Jerome Powell, James Bullard, and Neel Kashkari of the Fed.

There will be a bit more protein in the US’s economic release sandwich with no less than durable goods orders, house prices, consumer confidence, Richmond Fed manufacturing index, and new home sales.

The US Treasury will auction $44bn 5Y T-notes.

UK rates will no doubt remain in the driving seat today. The BoE’s statement released late in yesterday’s session (see above) didn’t seem to calm expectations of an emergency inter-meeting hike, but markets had only 30 minutes to react before the close. Today’s open will give a better idea of how the news has been processed, and if markets are ready to wait until the November meeting to see the BoE’s response.

Content Disclaimer

This publication has been prepared by ING solely for information purposes irrespective of a particular user's means, financial situation or investment objectives. The information does not constitute investment recommendation, and nor is it investment, legal or tax advice or an offer or solicitation to purchase or sell any financial instrument. Read more.

Original Post

Editor's Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.

This article was written by

From Trump to trade, FX to Brexit, ING’s global economists have it covered. Go to ING.com/THINK to stay a step ahead. We’re sorry we can’t reply to individuals' comments.Content disclaimer: The information in the publication is not an investment recommendation and it is not investment, legal or tax advice or an offer or solicitation to purchase or sell any financial instrument.This publication has been prepared by ING solely for information purposes without regard to any particular user's investment objectives, financial situation, or means. For our full disclaimer please click here.

Recommended For You

Comments (1)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.