An October 9, 2007 Wall Street Journal article describes new academic research that suggests foul play in hedge fund orchards everywhere. In "Pricing Tactics Of Hedge Funds Under Spotlight: Some Managers Select Favorable Valuations To Lift Performance," reporters David Reilly and Gregory Zuckerman cite empirical evidence that hedge fund managers may cherry pick prices of "hard to value" instruments as a way to pretty up performance.
The issue of valuing instruments for which no ready market exists is a challenge indeed. At a time when pension funds are allocating billions of dollars to hedge funds, private equity and venture capital pools, fiduciaries risk serious fallout if they fail to establish solid ground rules regarding valuation. There are any number of "must have" elements that comprise effective policies and procedures. Ignore them and plan sponsors lose a precious opportunity to detect possible trouble before things get out of hand.
Now is not the time to take shortcuts when it comes to valuing "hard to value" instruments or conducting proper oversight of portfolio managers who trade relatively illiquid stocks, bonds, derivatives and hybrids.