Currency ETFs: Consider the Commissions

Includes: DBV, ICI
by: Dividend Growth Investor

There are many currency ETFs out there covering not only major pairs such as the Euro, British Pound, Japanese Yen and Swiss Frank, but other exotic currencies such as the Chinese Yuan and the Brazilian Real. Currency ETFs provide investors with instruments that trade like stocks and could be bought, sold and sold short at any time that the stock market is open. Several companies offer ETFs on currencies and those include Barclays Bank, Deutsche Bank, Morgan Stanley, Wisdom Tree and Rydex.

In the process, these companies have raised almost 4.6 billion dollars for exchange traded funds or notes which simply hold underlying currencies. I didn’t include other ETFs that used strategies such as doubling the exposure to a specific currency, using a yield harvesting approach or ETFs tracking the US Dollar Index.

Before you rush into currency ETFs, however, there are the annual fees of .35% to 0.45 % for you to consider.

click to enlarge

In addition to that, because currency ETFs trade just like individual stocks, you have to pay a commission to enter and exit the fund.

Thus, on a $1000 investment in a currency ETF, you underperform the underlying by the amount of management fee, 0.4% plus a commission to buy the ETF, which will vary from $4 at Sharebuilder to $7 at Scottrade.
If you must buy and hold or simply trade a currency, why don’t you simply open a forex account at a well known broker such as Oanda, and then you won’t pay any management or stock trading fees. In addition to that, Oanda will add the interest to your account on a daily basis, which will allow for a faster compounding of the principal.

The only reason why one would hold currency ETFs as opposed to opening an account with a forex broker is if their 401K plan only offers a currency ETF and the investor must have some foreign currency exposure in a non taxable account.
To summarize, whenever you think about buying a new investment product, stop for a second and think how you can save money. Always check for alternatives whenever there are fees that you can avoid. If investors listen to this message, they will save approximately 19 million dollars annually just from avoiding annual management fees. How much could be saved from avoiding trading commissions could probably end up in millions of dollars as well.

[See here for list of Currency ETFs and ETNs]

About this article:

Want to share your opinion on this article? Add a comment.
Disagree with this article? .
To report a factual error in this article, click here