October 19, 2012 - 3 Deep Value Stocks by Zacks Investment Research
There are many ways to value a company. One of the most conservative ways is to take the value of a company's assets and subtract its liabilities. What's left over is the company's book value.
Of course, the value of a company's assets and liabilities are often subject to estimates by management and can include hard-to-measure intangibles like goodwill, patents and intellectual property. But if you strip out intangible assets and focus just on hard assets, and subtract the liabilities, you're left with the more conservative tangible book value.
Essentially, this is the what's left over for shareholders if a company were to liquidate all of its assets and pay off all of its obligations.
So how much are you willing to pay for a company's net assets? This usually depends on a how well the company is doing. Typically companies with strong returns on equity (ROE) and thus growing book values trade at high multiples to their book value.
But historically, stocks that trade at low price to book (P/B) multiples tend to outperform those with high price to book multiples.
S&P Cheap by Historical Standards
Currently the median price to book multiple on the S&P is 2.6, well below its 10-year median of 3.6. And the median ROE is increasing. That's a sign that the stock market may be undervalued.
And if you look hard enough, there are some great values out there.
3 Cheap Stocks
Theoretically a company shouldn't trade below its tangible book value. But I've found 3 that are currently doing just that, while also maintaining a solid ROE.
In other words, if these companies were to cease operations today, sell off all of their tangible assets and pay off all of their liabilities, what's left over would be worth more than their current stock price.
1. Fly Leasing Ltd (NYSE:FLY)
Return on Equity (NYSE:TTM): 17.0%
Return on Equity (5yr Avg): 11.5%
Price to Book Value: 0.7
Price to Tangible Book Value: 0.7
2. Tech Data Corp (NASDAQ:TECD)
Return on Equity (TTM): 10.8%
Return on Equity (5yr Avg): 8.9%
Price to Book Value: 0.9
Price to Tangible Book Value: 0.9
3. Kelly Services (NASDAQ:KELYA)
Return on Equity (TTM): 9.6%
Return on Equity (5yr Avg): 3.6%
Price to Book Value: 0.7
Price to Tangible Book Value: 0.8
The Bottom Line
Think of tangible book value as what would be left over for shareholders if a company were to liquidate all of its assets and pay off all of its obligations. It is rare for stocks to trade below this level, especially ones with positive returns on equity. But these 3 are currently doing just that.
Value Investing Stock Picks of Guru Investors
GuruFocus is dedicated to value investing. As employed by Warren Buffett, the greatest investor of all time, value investing is the only winning strategy for the long term. GuruFocus hosts numerous value screeners and research tools, and regularly publishes articles about value investing strategies and ideas. GuruFocus also publishes three newsletters: Monthly Ben Graham Net-Net, Buffett-Munger Best Bargains and Microcap Magic Formula Stocks.