In one of the best IPO results of the year, the first restaurant IPO of the year, Noodles (NDLS) raised almost $100M and stock price more than doubled from its initial pricing at $18 to close at $36.75 on its first day. The Noodles CEO, Kevin Reddy, came from Chipotle (CMG), at an earlier stop in life.
Is Noodles today's Chipotle? Chipotle IPO'd in June 2006. They are both fast casual concepts, Colorado based, both early movers. And there are many fundamentals comparisons. See the table below, prepared from both the Noodles and the Chipotle SEC S-1s, for their last full fiscal year before IPO, which shows the key fundamentals drivers:
|Fundamentals Parameter||Chipotle, FY 2005||Noodles, FY 2012|
|IPO Timing||June 2006||June 2013|
|Average Annual Sales/Unit||$1,440,000||$1,178,000|
|Restaurant Level Margin||18.2%||20.3%|
|Enterprise EBITDA % (book)||9.4%||9.2%|
|Net Income $||$30,240,000||$5,200,000|
|Number of Units||481||327|
|Same Store Sales||+10.2%||+5.2%|
|% Company owned||100%||84%|
|Lead Underwriters||Morgan Stanley, Cowen||Morgan Stanley, Cowen|
|Sponsor||McDonald's (MCD)||Catterton, Argentia/Canadian Pension|
Store economics look similar? Yes, in some ways:
· Fast casual operators, new buildings, new food types and popularized styles.
· Average Annual Restaurant Sales in the $1.2M to $1.4M range.
· Solid restaurant margins-Noodles now actually exceeded that of Chipotle in 2005 by 210 bpts.
· Totally or primarily company operated model.
Noodles' success demonstrates there is investor demand for new restaurant offerings and validates fast casual investor demand. I understand NDLS was twenty times oversubscribed. Catterton, Morgan Stanley and Cowen did a nice job.
The issue to keep in mind is the United States consumer space is not the same as it was in 2006. Recession, fundamental changes in population, income, eating and dining preferences, commercial real estate site characteristics, and more US restaurants in operation each year make for a more difficult 2013 and out conditions.
Noodles must deliver good quality, service, cleanliness and price/value, in a differentiated fashion, with good corporate stewardship and continue to build connections with guests, employees, investors and other stakeholders via it's culture.
Mathematically, as it expands, it has to think a lot about occupancy costs. NDLS occupancy costs are now 9.9%. Chipotle's was 7.6% in 2005. Site supply is tight. Many legacy brands, the real first movers, like McDonald's (MCD) and Dunkin Brands (DNKN) got the early best US sites. Restaurants economics was built on 6-8% rent, but some restaurant operations are facing 15-20% rent for some sites. Too much push for too fast expansion will test the rent leverage especially for a $1.2 million sales concept.
The imputed IPO valuation from the NDLS IPO is already $800M, or an EV/EBITDA multiple of 26.6X. That's rich. But it's just the first day. I hope the pressure cooker investment world will take a break and give them a chance to grow smartly.
Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.