Please Note: Blog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors.

Japan Sows The Seeds Of Destruction - November 4, 2014

|Includes: DAL, EWZ, LUV, United Continental Holdings, Inc (UAL)

Click here to see the full post


I'm increasingly convinced that Japan will be the epicenter of the next financial crisis. It's hard to be surprised by the Bank of Japan's latest QE expansion, because I noted the possibility in a comment to Marketfy subscribers after Wednesday's FOMC meeting. However, the obvious collusion between the BoJ and GPIF, Japan's government pension fund, seems almost devious.

In case you missed it, just hours before the BoJ announcement, GPIF officials approved new allocation targets that will raise the fund's holdings of Japanese equities to 25% of the portfolio from the current 12%. Asset allocation is a zero-sum game, so in order to free up cash the fund will sell longer-dated Japanese government bonds (JGBs). GPIF's allocations are closely watched because a 1% shift means a transfer of more than $10 billion.

Conveniently enough the BoJ's ever-expanding balance sheet will start adding more longer-dated JGBs. The central bank literally can't buy enough T-bills on the open market (at negative yields), so it's shifting to a more liquid part of the curve; effectively subsidizing the public pensions.

Bank of Japan Balance Sheet as a % of Nominal GDP

Oh, and by the way, there are few signs this is working. CPI growth is non-existent even though the BoJ's balance sheet is now 60% of nominal GDP (chart above). The BoJ was already running the wildest monetary experiment in history before Friday's announcement, but now they're operating in a manner that would make Paul Krugman blush.

It's Election Day here in the US, not that anybody cares. The US ranks 120th globally with a voter turnout rate of 66.5%; nearly 30% behind world #1 Australia (94.5%). According to Nate Silver's, Republicans have a 62% chance of winning a Senate majority and several gubernatorial races are considered toss-ups.

We made a few adjustments to our portfolio last Friday ahead of the vote. Republican control of Congress would have significant implications for several industries. For example, emerging threats like the Islamic State combined with a Republican Senate could lead to an easing of mandatory cuts in the US defense budget. The cuts aren't due to resume until 2016, but markets are always forward looking and will start to price-in these factors after the elections results.

We're not positioned very aggressively at the moment. I feel good about our uncorrelated bets and the returns have been steady. Heck, we're beating the hell out of most hedge funds this year. And that's just in stocks. I've had a monster year in FX, and not only because of the recent US dollar rally. I'm pressing Marketfy to add FX capabilities, and hopefully they'll be available soon. In the meantime, if you'd like to know what stocks I'm referencing please click here for more info. Your subscription will pay for itself in no time.

Today's letter will cover several topics, including:

  • Buffoons in Brazil
  • Greenspan sounds off
  • Growth in airlines?
  • Chart of the Week

As always, if you have any questions or comments or just want to vent, please send me an email at

Until next time, tread lightly out there,

Michael Lingenheld

Managing Editor - Cup & Handle Macro

Brazil is Baffling

Brazil is in a major pickle. The country re-elected President Dilma Rousseff last week proving they didn't learn any lessons from her first term. The economy contracted in the second quarter and is expected to do so again in the third quarter, which would make this Brazil's first recession since 2009. The unemployment rate is only 5.0%, but that's being driven by a decline in the participation rate - similar to the US. The real issue is inflation. The Brazilian central bank has an inflation target of 4.5%; a level that's been overshot since early 2010.

Brazil CPI Y/Y

Brazil GDP Y/Y

Even in the face stagflation, last week the central bank hiked interest rates 25 bps to 11.25%, surprising analysts who had predicted no change. Throughout her campaign Ms. Rousseff warned the electorate that Aecio Neves, the pro-business candidate, would raise rates so high to quell inflation that he would cause a recession and high unemployment. First of all, the central bank is independent. The President has no control over interest rates. Secondly, Brazil is already headed for recession and capital is pouring out of the country. Alas, Brazilian voters know where their bread is buttered. Since Rousseff's party took control of the Presidency 12 years ago, the minimum wage has increased 84% adjusting for inflation; proving once again that elections can be bought.



Rousseff must now convince ratings agencies that she knows what she's doing, which could prove to be difficult. Higher interest rates will help, but the Brazilian Real (BRL) is at risk of falling to the lowest level against USD since 2005, exacerbating the inflation problem in the process. Brazil's stock market has been in a bear market for several years now. Unless you have some reason to be optimistic on commodities, the Brazilian ETF (EWZ) should continue to be a short. If EWZ breaks through the previous low of $38/share it could drop to $30 very quickly.

Greenspan gets it

Even at the age of 88, former Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan still has a firm grasp of markets. Speaking to the Council of Foreign Relations last week, Greenspan said he doesn't think the Fed can unwind years of extraordinary stimulus without igniting some market turmoil. This sounds eerily similar to Julian Robertson's comments from September when he said, "bonds are at ridiculous levels, and the bubble will end in a very bad way."

While the Fed's bond-buying program has been a "terrific success" in boosting asset prices, Greenspan noted "effective demand is dead in the water" and the effort to boost it via QE "has not worked." Asked about opportunities in the market, Greenspan said gold is a good place to put money these days given its value as a currency outside of the policies conducted by governments. I might not buy gold in USD at the moment, but given his rationale, it would be interesting to know what Greenspan thinks about Bitcoin.

The Airline Graveyard

It's one of the most stunning statements in finance: "The airline industry, in its history, has never made money." It seems impossible until you remember the three largest legacy airlines - American (NASDAQ:AAL), United (NYSE:UAL) and Delta (NYSE:DAL) - have all filed for bankruptcy over the past 12 years. Not only that, but each has merged with another large carrier that had also sought legal protection from creditors.

In March 2013, Guggenheim liquidated its Airline ETF (ticker: FAA) after it failed to attract meaningful inflows. Since then, the HYSE Arca Global Airline Index has rallied more than 78% - one of the best runs in the history of airliners.

FAA had $21 million in AUM when it closed, more than 500 ETFs today. If it hadn't closed, it would have been able to cross the $50 million mark - roughly the amount an ETF needs to be profitable - on market performance alone.

NYSE Arca Global Airline Index

Why the turnaround? Airliners have finally started to make money. American and United both announced stock buybacks greater than $1 billion. American also announced its first dividend payment since 1980. As an industry, airliners reported record operating results in the third quarter, and management commentary suggests fourth-quarter results could be just as strong.

The increased profitability is occurring for two reasons. First, continued strong travel demand is allowing airlines to push fares higher. Even the threat of Ebola has had little impact on travel. Second, jet fuel prices, which account 1/3 of costs, have plummeted alongside crude oil. United cut its fuel bill by $135 million compared with last year's third quarter, a reduction of 4.1% on its largest single expense.

Should you get involved? If you think this airliner rally has legs I would recommend using the relative value technique we discussed in last week's note. Specifically, I would try to own airlines operating primarily domestic flights and sell international carriers. Southwest, for example, mainly operates in the continental US; whereas United flies everywhere. It even has a decent chart.

Southwest (NYSE:LUV) / United (UAL)

Outright exposure to airlines is risky, especially with a stagnant economy and the potential for higher oil prices. However, on a relative basis there is money to be made here.

Chart of the Week

In last week's Macro Rundown video I introduced a new theme highlighting EM countries vulnerable to a surging US dollar. I still think Turkey is the most vulnerable, but South Africa is running a close second. The unemployment rate is above 25%, CPI is running above 6% Y/Y, GDP growth has slowed to 1.0% Y/Y and the President is a crook. In fact, President Zuma went to court asking that affidavits saying he is a "corrupt crook" be removed. Not that anyone thinks South African courts are legitimate after the Oscar Pistorius trial.

US Dollar / South African Rand

Needless to say I think the South African Rand (ZAR) will continue to fall against the US dollar, but I'd like to highlight this remarkable chart. Since July 2011, USD/ZAR has tested this trend-line (which is more-or-less the 50-week moving average) upwards of six times and never broken through. Trends like this make managing risk very easy, because there is such an obvious stop-level. Some of you might not be interested in buying here after such a strong move, but the chart and fundamentals are indicating this rally is far from over.

Reader Question:

**Editor's note: Every week we'll try to answer at least one reader question. If you would like to submit a question, please send us an email at We'd love to hear from you! **

Q: What's your opinion of Bitcoin? - EL

A: I've been meaning to write about Bitcoin for a long time, and will do so eventually. I am very bullish Bitcoin over the long-term. The big obstacle at the moment is an easy-to-use platform that makes Bitcoin transactions simple, but there are thousands of (very smart) software developers working to solve that problem. Millenials, especially those in Asia, are a tech-savvy generation attracted to the concept of a decentralized currency. Everything else in their lives is decentralized. Music, news, even personal relationships are all stored remotely via "the cloud" these days, so why not your savings? Bitcoin is outside the banking system, therefore immune to manipulation (even gold can't say that) and we know there is a fixed supply. That means the price will ultimately be driven by demand, and I think there will be a lot of it.

That's all, see you next week!

For any questions or comments, please email us at:

Please visit us at:

Follow us on Twitter: @cuphandlemacro

Disclaimer: None of the information contained in this publication constitutes a recommendation that any particular investment, security, portfolio, transaction or investment strategy is suitable for any specific person. This publication may contain news, information, speculation, rumors, opinions and/or commentary. Cup & Handle Macro Research, LLC ("C&H"), is not permitted to offer personalized trading or investment advice to subscribers. C&H is not a broker/dealer, an exchange or a futures commission merchant and is not subject to regulation by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission or any similar regulatory authority in connection with its activities. C&H does not act as an investment adviser or a commodity trading advisor and does not provide any investment advice or commodity trading advice. The information, statements, views and opinions included in this publication are based on sources (both internal and external) considered to be reliable, but no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to their accuracy, completeness or correctness, including without limitation, any implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for use for a particular purpose, accuracy or non-infringement. Use of any information obtained from or through this publication is entirely at your own risk. C&H does not routinely moderate, screen or edit any third party content. Such information, statements, views and opinions are expressed as of the date of publication, are subject to change without further notice and do not constitute a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any investment referenced in the publication.


Employees and/or affiliates of C&H may give advice and take action with respect to clients and/or investments that differs from the information, statements, views and opinions included in this publication. Nothing herein or in the subscription agreement shall limit or restrict the right of employees or affiliates of C&H to perform investment management, advisory or other services for any persons or entities. In addition, nothing herein or in the subscription agreement shall limit or restrict employees or affiliates of C&H from buying, selling or trading securities or other investments for their personal or other related accounts, or for the accounts of their clients. Employees or affiliates of C&H may at any time have, acquire, increase, decrease or dispose of the securities or other investments referenced in this publication. C&H shall have no obligation whatsoever to recommend securities or investments in this publication as a result of its employees' or affiliates' investment activities for their own accounts or for any other accounts.

This publication is proprietary and intended solely for the use of its subscribers, and is protected by domestic and international copyright laws. No license is granted to any subscriber, except for the subscriber's personal use. No part of this publication or its contents may be copied, downloaded, stored, further transmitted, or otherwise reproduced, transferred, or used, in any form or by any means, except as expressly permitted under the subscription agreement or with the prior written permission of C&H. Any further disclosure or use, distribution, dissemination or copying of this publication, or any portion hereof, is strictly prohibited.

There is no guarantee that this site will operate in an uninterrupted or error-free manner or is free of viruses or other harmful components. This publication assumes no responsibility for any omission, interruption, deletion, defect, delay in operation or transmission, communications line failure, theft or destruction or unauthorized access to, or alteration hereof. The publication is not responsible for any technical malfunction or other problems of any computer, telephone or other equipment, or software occurring for any reason, including but not limited to, technical problems or traffic congestion on the Internet or at any site or with respect to this publication or combination thereof, including injury or damage to any person's computer, mobile phone, or other hardware or software, related to or resulting from using or downloading any content hereof.

Disclosure: The author has no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.