The P&G Board: Too Much Of A Good Thing?

Jul. 19, 2012 9:15 PM ETPG
Please Note: Blog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors.

Contributor Since 2009

Patricia Lenkov is the Founder and CEO of Agility Executive Search. A well known name in New York executive search firm circles, Ms. Lenkov also served in the Board of Directors Practice at Spencer Stuart and spent six and a half years with Heidrick & Struggles where she conducted C-level and board searches for such companies as: Harris Corporation, IKON Office Solutions, Tomkins PLC and BellSouth Corporation. Throughout her executive search industry career, her diverse duties lead her to structure full boards for pre-IPO companies, spinouts and divestitures. Ms. Lenkov has also conducted cross border recruitment of directors and CEO’s for major European and Canadian companies and has lead in conducting senior management assignments for Xerox, Seagram’s, Citadel Investment Group and AlliedSignal Inc (now Honeywell International Inc.). Before joining the executive search industry Ms. Lenkov served as a Quebec Regional Sales Manager for a Silicon Valley based company and has held a variety of sales and marketing positions in both Canada and the US. Prior to this, she was the Assistant Director of the MBA Program at Concordia University, one of Canada’s most dynamic and innovative universities with approximately 44,000 students. Active in her community, Patricia is involved with The Young Women’s Leadership Foundation as well as The Blue Card, Inc. She serves diligently on the Family Advisory Council of the Komansky Center for Children’s Health at New York-Presbyterian Hospital Weill Cornell Medical Center and is on the Board of Directors of Temple Israel of New York City. She is also a Parents Association Committee Chair at The Collegiate School. Ms. Lenkov holds a BA (with Distinction) in Psychology from McGill University and an MBA from Concordia University. She resides in Manhattan with her husband, daughter and twin boys.

Several conditions make a company attractive to an activist investor. Per the Milken Institute, these include an undervalued business, poor share price performance, failure to meet communicated goals and the company being a conglomerate or mini-conglomerate.

Bill Ackman's Pershing Square Capital Management recently announced a $2 billion investment for a 1% stake in Proctor & Gamble (P&G). P&G, with 2011 sales of $82.5 billion represents a significant target for Pershing Square and is in fact the firm's largest investment ever. It will be interesting to watch these powerful forces collide.

At the center of much of the criticism of P&G is CEO Robert MacDonald who took the helm of the company in 2009 after a well-planned and executed succession planning process. In fact, P&G is an oft-cited case for succession planning best practices. They have a succession planning program that has been consistently studied and replicated. As a big believer in the advantages of planned and strategic succession, even I have used P&G as an example in my teaching on the subject. Yet, Robert MacDonald, the hand-picked and groomed successor to A.G.Lafley (P&G's former Chairman, President & CEO) is being blamed for the lackluster results P&G has been experiencing lately. As such, it is being speculated that he will be the initial target of the changes Bill Ackman is looking to make.

Subsequent to this, the focus most certainly will turn to the board of directors. According to research at NYU's Stern School of Business out of 151 activist hedge fund targets studied between 2003 and 2005, activist shareholders received a seat on the board about 44% of the time (this number is surely on the rise). So, what will Ackman find as he and his team begins to scrutinize the P&G boardroom?

In addition to CEO Robert MacDonald, P&G has a stellar group of seriously accomplished executives in their boardroom. The CEO's of some of this country's largest and best known companies are directors of P&G. This includes Ken Chenault of American Express, Jim McNerney of Boeing, Meg Whitman of HP and Pat Woertz of Archer Daniels Midland. With such a stellar cast of characters, is there anything that Ackman can find to improve?

The answer is, as it always is, yes! Eight out of the ten independent directors on the P&G board are active CEO's and six of the eight are also the Chair of their company's board. Additionally, six of the ten independent directors have a board seat in addition to their own and P&G. This means that these active CEOs are sitting on two or more outside boards for a total of three (and in one case four) board commitments. That is a lot of responsibility. The convention these days for sitting CEOs is to participate in one or oftentimes, no outside boards.

Speaking of multiple commitments, serving on a board these days can take upwards of 20 hours a month (PWC reported this in 2009). Add to this the consuming responsibility of running a multi-national, multi-billion publicly traded company in these days of tough economic times and increasing demands from all sides and that doesn't leave a lot of time even for the most efficient and effective.

In 2011, 59% of P&G's sales came from outside North America. Asia currently represents 16% and is contributing double-digit growth to the company. Overall P&G is experiencing disproportionate growth from developing regions yet the only non-American on the board is Ernesto Zedillo, former President of Mexico. The company and/or Ackman would be prudent to eventually add an executive from any of a variety of emerging markets. Someone with "on-the-ground" operating experience from one or more of the 180 countries P&G does business in could be invaluable.

Ackman may eventually make a big deal out of some interlocks that exist on the P&G board as this type of circumstance is ripe for the focus of an investor looking for lapses of any kind (remember the resume fiasco at Yahoo that now seems like ancient history!) Both Ken Chenault and James McNerney sit on the IBM board in addition to P&G. Bob MacDonald and Mary Alice Wilderotter, another P&G director, also sit on the board of Xerox. Finally, P&G director Scott Cook who is the President of Intuit also sits on the Ebay board. He has sat on Ebay since 1998, the year Meg Whitman became CEO of the company. So he and Whitman spent nine years in the boardroom at Ebay and now they serve together on the P&G board. All of these connections make for a collegial group that has a lot in common but the familiarity can breed an environment that is too amicable and perhaps too tight-knit.

Finally, while it is extremely desirable to have CEO expertise on a board of directors some diversity of skills is important as well. Perhaps Ackman is going to push for some online marketing, social media, technology or supply chain talent. In any case, even on a board jammed with high-profile and accomplished leaders there is always room for some improvement!

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

Recommended For You


To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.