Gold vs. realized inflation
The chart below shows the inflation rate (CPI Yoy) vs. the price of gold. It is clear that the lines appear to be correlated back in the 70’s and 80's, but lose their relationship in the past decade. This makes it difficult to believe that the recent increase in the price of gold has been solely due to changes in realized inflation.
Gold vs. inflation expectations
One might reason that it is not realized inflation that gold is a hedge for, but the expected inflation rate. Below we show the same graph of gold prices, but this time we compare it to the University of Michigan Survey of Inflation Expectations 1year out. Again, we see a correlation in the late 70’s and early 80's, but nothing compelling in the past decade.
Gold vs. Breakeven rate
It is conceivable (though frankly not probable) that because the Michigan Inflation Sentiment surveys the general population, the survey results are not representative of inflation sentiment amongst financial market participants. In the graph below, we show gold prices vs. the 30 year breakeven inflation rate (the breakeven inflation rate is calculated from the difference in yields from 30 yr inflation linked bonds and treasuries). You see that in recent years the market implied inflation rate 30 years out is only ~2%, which is in line with inflation expectations in the previous decade and does not signify high inflation expectations.
Gold vs. Federal Reserve Balance Sheet
One might argue that the recent increase in value of gold is due to the radical increase in the size of the Fed’s balance sheet, but for one reason or another, this hasn’t been reflected in the inflation expectations of the market (a dubious claim, but one we’ll examine). Here is a graph showing YoY changes to the Fed’s balance sheet alongside gold prices. Again, we do not see any compelling relationship. The large increase in the Fed’s balance sheet in 2008 actually coincided with a decrease in the price of gold and prior increases in Fed’s balance sheet did not coincide with increases in the price of gold.
There isn’t much empirical evidence to make one believe that the decade long gold rally has to do exclusively with either realized inflation, inflation expectations or the federal reserves balance sheet. However, based upon our previous article about the macro exposure obtained by buying/selling gold, thinking of gold simply as a hedge for inflation may miss the bigger picture. The fundamental reason gold has value is that it is an alternative to paper currency, and what makes gold attractive to hold vs. a paper currency is what it yields on a real basis. While high inflation rates might be one variable that goes into determining whether a currency is attractive to hold, it is likely not the whole picture. It is important to understand that the exposure you obtain from buying/selling gold is not exclusively linked to the inflation rate.
Seeking Alpha's Disclosure: Past performance is no guarantee of future results. No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment is suitable for a particular investor. Any views or opinions expressed above may not reflect those of Seeking Alpha as a whole. Seeking Alpha is not a licensed securities dealer, broker or US investment adviser or investment bank. Our analysts are third party authors that include both professional investors and individual investors who may not be licensed or certified by any institute or regulatory body.