"Kicking Myself" Shoes

Dec. 06, 2013 7:31 PM ETEPB
Factoids profile picture
Factoids's Blog
4.8K Followers
Please Note: Blog posts are not selected, edited or screened by Seeking Alpha editors.

Dividend Investing, Growth At A Reasonable Price

Contributor Since 2011

I seek to liberate investors from the chains of borrowed opinions by teaching metric awareness that leads to the formation of your own opinions. I am a retail investor that gathers, processes and analyzes significantly more data than average. I share that data in my articles. I let the data do the talking. I am only taking dictation as the data tells its message.

I knew that EPB had a falling CAGR. I knew EPB had a poor distribution/DCF ratio. But only one brokerage gave EPB a forward CAGR in the twos. Since it was an outlier forecast - I failed to heed that warning. I sold my EPB today (Friday 12-06-13) - after it had already fallen 9% on Wednesday and 4% on Thursday. Below is my "Yield plus CAGR" spreadsheet from market's close on Thursday:

Yield + CAGR Total Return Expectations

 

 


Company Q4-13 Consensus Total Bonds DCF My Total Rtn Consensus Pr Impl Distrib
    Yield CAGR Return Ratings Accr RRRs - RRR Ratings CAGR / DCF
Large Cap Midstream
Buckeye BPL 6.46% 4.00% 10.46% BBB- 2.30 10.40 0.06 2.5 3.94 89.77
Boardwalk BWP 8.77% 1.50% 10.27% BBB 3.20 10.70 -0.43 2.9 1.93 104.93
El Paso EPB 7.47% 2.00% 9.47% BBB- 1.20 10.30 -0.83 2.9 2.83 95.59
Enbridge EEP 7.42% 2.70% 10.12% BBB 2.40 10.50 -0.38 2.5 3.08 97.93
Enterprise EPD 4.49% 6.70% 11.19% BBB+ 1.20 9.70 1.49 1.7 5.21 67.81
Energy Trans ETP 6.73% 3.50% 10.23% BBB- 3.00 10.70 -0.47 2.5 3.97 78.87
Kinder Morgan KMP 6.81% 4.50% 11.31% BBB 1.00 10.00 1.31 2.7 3.19 94.41
Magellan MMP 3.75% 8.80% 12.55% BBB 1.00 10.00 2.55 2.5 6.25 75.34
NuStar NS 8.80% 1.50% 10.30% BB+ 4.00 12.00 -1.70 3.3 3.20 114.36
OneOK OKS 5.56% 6.70% 12.26% BBB 1.50 10.50 1.76 3.0 4.94 88.15
Plains All-Am PAA 4.87% 8.50% 13.37% BBB 1.00 10.00 3.37 1.9 5.13 71.64
Williams WPZ 7.14% 5.40% 12.54% BBB 3.00 11.00 1.54 2.3 3.86 99.15

Average   6.52% 4.65% 11.17%         2.56

Company Q4-13 Consensus Total Bonds DCF My Total Rtn Consensus Pr Impl Distrib
    Yield CAGR Return Ratings Accr RRRs - RRR Ratings CAGR / DCF
Small Cap Midstream
BlueKnight BKEP 5.44% 9.00% 14.44% NR 4.00 13.00 1.44 3.5 7.56 47.57
Genesis GEL 4.21% 8.70% 12.91% BB- 2.70 11.80 1.11 1.8 7.59 70.37
Holly HEP 6.24% 6.00% 12.24% BB 1.30 11.20 1.04 3.3 4.96 87.56
Spectra SEP 4.88% 6.80% 11.68% BBB 2.20 10.50 1.18 2.9 5.62 72.46
Sunco SXL 3.71% 8.90% 12.61% BBB- 1.00 10.00 2.61 2.7 6.29 54.08
TCPipelines TCP 7.06% 3.00% 10.06% BBB 1.00 10.00 0.06 3.2 2.94 89.26
Transmontaigne TLP 6.17% 3.00% 9.17% NR 1.20 10.00 -0.83 1.7 3.83 72.22

Average   5.39% 6.49% 11.87%         2.73

Company Q4-13 Consensus Total Bonds DCF My Total Rtn Consensus Pr Impl Distrib
    Yield CAGR Return Ratings Accr RRRs - RRR Ratings CAGR / DCF
Gathering & Processing
Access ACMP 4.16% 9.60% 13.76% BB- 1.50 12.00 1.76 1.7 7.84 67.72
American AMID 7.60% 4.50% 12.10% NR 5.00 12.50 -0.40 1.4 4.90 80.09
Atlas Pipelines APL 7.27% 9.10% 16.37% B+ 5.00 13.50 2.87 1.4 6.23 83.22
Crestwood CMLP 7.42% 5.00% 12.42% B- 3.70 12.50 -0.08 2.1 5.08 80.60
DCP Partners DPM 6.14% 6.70% 12.84% BBB- 2.70 11.50 1.34 2.1 5.36 85.21
Eagle Rock EROC 11.03% 0.10% 11.13% B 5.00 13.50 -2.37 2.6 2.47 100.00
Exterran EXLP 8.00% 3.00% 11.00% B- 2.20 11.50 -0.50 2.5 3.50 79.03
Mark West MWE 5.16% 8.70% 13.86% BB 3.20 12.50 1.36 1.7 7.34 69.39
Targa NGLS 5.82% 6.90% 12.72% BB 1.70 12.20 0.52 1.9 6.38 84.44
Regency RGP 7.70% 4.00% 11.70% BB- 3.20 12.00 -0.30 2.6 4.30 88.68
Western WES 3.84% 9.30% 13.14% BBB- 1.70 11.20 1.94 1.9 7.36 77.59
Cross-Tex XTEX 5.09% 8.50% 13.59% B+ 4.00 13.50 0.09 2.3 8.41 82.50

Average   6.60% 6.28% 12.89%         2.02

Even after the dramatic fall in unit price, EPB still sold at a price-implied CAGR of 2.8% while next year's guidance is for growth that is just under 2%.

The moral of the story: CONTINUOUSS AND FREQUENTLY UPDATED due diligence matters. Due diligence updated less frequently is bad due diligence.

Disclosure: I am long CMLP, DPM, EPD, GEL, KMP, MMP, MWE, WES.

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.