The energy sector is tanking and here are five of the year's poorest performing ETFs

Epic view on Large offshore 8MW wind turbines, wind farm on the horizont in north sea with jack up boat and offshore platform in wavy sea
CharlieChesvick/E+ via Getty Images

  • Oil prices are sinking and energy stocks are tanking the most among the S&P 500's 11 sectors Monday amid a broad market sell-off -- and surprisingly, green energy isn't providing much of a refuge.
  • Many green-energy stocks are falling for the day, and ecofriendly ETFs are some of the the worst year-to-date performers among the energy sector's 66 ETFs and 13 sub-sectors.
  • While green-energy ETFs have great one- and five-year performance records, they've been hurting since the year began.
  • Cowan stated in a recent note: “Investor enthusiasm for green investments has heightened in recent times, with a particular focus on solar as conversations are becoming reminiscent of 4Q20.”
  • Here's a rundown of the energy segment's five worst-performing subsectors year to day, along with the poorest performing exchange traded funds in each. All figures are per, and the rundown excludes leveraged and inverse ETFs:

Fifth-Worst Segment: Solar Energy

  • This segment is up just 2.35% year to date on average among the two ETFs offered, badly trailing the S&P 500's roughly 15% YTD gain.
  • The poorest performer of the two is the Invesco Solar ETF (NYSEARCA:TAN) which is 21.54% YTD.
  • TAN’s top three holdings are in Enphase Energy (11.34%), SolarEdge Technologies (10.01%) and Sunrun (7.18%).
  • On the plus side, TAN's one-year performance is is +88.04%, while its five-year gains total 277.13%.

Fourth-Worst Segment: Wind Energy

  • Wind Energy is 10.3% YTD, but that's all attributable to First Trust Global Wind Energy ETF (NYSEARCA:FAN), which is the sector's only ETF.
  • That said, FAN looks much better longer term. From a one-year performance standpoint, the ETF is +31.28%, and on a five-year return, FAN is +61.89%.
  • FAN’s top three holdings are Vestas Wind Systems A/S (8.42%), Northland Power (7.78%) and Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy (7.26%).

Third-Worst Segment: YieldCos

  • YieldCos are part of an emerging asset class that focuses on returning cash flows from renewable energy assets to shareholders.
  • The space only has one ETF so far - the Global X Funds Global X Renewable Energy Producers ETF (NASDAQ:RNRG) - which is -11.03% YTD.
  • Break down RNRG’s holdings and investors will see the top three holdings are Verbund AG (6.89%), Centrais Eletricas Brasileiras (5.88%) and Brookfield Renewable Partners (5.63%).

Second-Worst Segment: Clean Energy

  • This energy segment is represented by seven different exchange traded funds that have a -8.52 average YTD return.
  • Invesco WilderHill Clean Energy ETF (NYSEARCA:PBW) is the segment's worst-performing fund, as it is -21.86% YTD.
  • But in the longer view, PBW is +69.67% in one-year performance and +311.56% over five years.
  • PBW's top three holdings are JinkoSolar Holding Co Ltd ADR (2.42%), Maxeon Solar Technologies (1.92%) and Azure Power Global (1.91%).
  • No. 1 Worst Performing Segment: Cleantech
  • Cleantech has one ETF - The exchange traded fund that represents the segment - which is -14.10% YTD.
  • That said, ERTH is +22.94% on a one-year basis and +109.59% over five years.
  • ERTH’s top three holdings are NIO Inc (6.94%), Tesla (5.19%) and Vestas Wind Systems (4.64%).
  • Here's a look at how ERTH, PBW, RNRG, FAN and TAN fared against each other on a one-month chart:

  • Looking at the longer term, all of these ETFs funds except RNRG have outperformed the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (NYSEARCA:SPY) over the past three years:

Recommended For You

Comments (8)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.