ETF Pullback Choices: Respecting Dartboards and Clueless Forecasters

Jun. 23, 2011 3:42 PM ET, , , ,
Marc Gerstein
6.67K Followers

Did you ever just look at a list of stocks or ETFs, roll your eyes, and feel tempted to start shopping on line for a dartboard? That’s pretty much how I felt looking this week at the list produced by my ETF Pullback strategy (see Appendix below for details and performance information). Here’s the current list:

  • PowerShares DB Commodity (DBC)
  • WisdomTree International Real Estate (DRW)
  • iShares MSCI Switzerland (EWL)
  • Market Vectors Poland (PLND)
  • PowerShares S&P SmallCap Energy (PSCE)

Here was last week’s list:

  • PowerShares DB Silver Fund (DBS)
  • CurrencyShares Swedish Krona (FXS)
  • Market Vectors Poland (PLND)
  • ETFS Silver Trust (SIVR)
  • iShares Silver Trust (SLV)

(I suppose this might be a good time to mention that if that dartboard approach is starting to intrigue you, the Winmau Blade III Bristle Dartboard is ranked 5-star by 64 reviewers on Amazon.com.)

For those who aren’t yet ready to go the dartboard route, I need to start by noting that the PowerShares DB commodity fund serves as a reminder of how we can’t always rely on the name of an ETF to cue us as to the factors likely to most heavily influence its performance. It appears to provide general commodities exposure. It does, indeed, touch on all the major categories. But about half the portfolio is energy with another 10% consisting of precious metals. If you’re interested in things like industrial metals, grains, softs, etc., this is not the best choice for you.

As to the energy exposure, I’m not sure how I feel this at present. The first time I looked at today’s headlines, it appeared that oil had finished correcting and was poised to recover a bit in response to reports of lower inventories. Barely an hour later, it appeared that oil would continue to fall given the prospect of ongoing economic sluggishness. Who can

This article was written by

6.67K Followers
After 43+ years working for one investment research company or another, I finally retired. So now, I’m completely independent. And for the first time on Seeking Alpha, I won’t be working based on anybody else’s product agenda. I have only one goal now… to give you the best actionable investment insights I can.I have long specialized in rules/factor-based equity investing strategies. But I’m different from others who share such backgrounds. I don’t serve the numbers. Instead, the numbers serve me… to inspire HI (Human Intelligence) generated investment stories. I definitely understand quant investing, including factors and what not (AI before it was called AI). But I don't agree with what other quants do. Rather than be obsessed with statistical studies that are no good for any time periods other than the ones studied, I combine factor work with the underlying theories of finance including classic fundamental analysis to get the true story of a company and its stock. Investing is about the future. So numbers (which necessarily live in the past) can take us just so far. They’re at their best when they cue us into stories that shed light on what’s likely to happen in the future. And that’s how I use them,I’ve had a pretty colorful career. Besides a full range of experience covering stocks from lots of different groups (large cap, small cap, micro cap, value, growth, income, special situations … you name it, I covered it) I’ve developed and worked with many different quant models. In addition, I formerly managed a high-yield fixed-income (“junk bond”) fund and conducted research involving quantitative asset allocation strategies such as are at the foundation of what today has come to be known as Robo Advising. I formerly edited and or wrote several stock newsletters, the most noteworthy having been the Forbes Low Priced Stock Report. I previously served as an assistant research director at Value Line.I also have long had a passion for investor education, which has resulted in my having conducted numerous seminars on stock selection and analysis, and the authoring of two books: Screening The Market and The Value Connection.I’m looking forward to my new incarnation on Seeking Alpha. I hope you enjoy what I offer. But if you don’t, feel free to tell me why in the comment sections. I’m a big boy. I can handle criticism. (But please don’t call me “stupid.” That’s my wife’s job!)

Recommended For You

Related Stocks

SymbolLast Price% Chg
DBC--
Invesco DB Commodity Index Tracking Fund ETF
WTRE--
WisdomTree New Economy Real Estate ETF
EWL--
iShares MSCI Switzerland ETF
PLND--
VanEck Vectors Poland ETF
PSCE--
Invesco S&P SmallCap Energy ETF

Related Analysis