Bad News Is Good, Good News Is Bad For Stocks... Except For This Week

Aug. 11, 2022 12:35 PM ETCarvana Co. (CVNA), ROKUDOCU, SHOP, SHOP:CA, SPOT, UPST31 Comments
Steven Cress profile picture
Steven Cress


  • July CPI results are in, and the markets rallied on news that U.S. inflation is experiencing some cooling. CPI of 8.5% is good news, and the markets are responding favorably.
  • Beware! Irrational exuberance may be prompting investors to invest in stocks that have fallen amid market volatility, negative investor sentiment, and earnings miss that are now rallying following CPI news.
  • Weeks of the bear bounce have given way to good news that was bad for the stock market, and bad news that resulted in the markets reacting positively.
  • Avoid being caught off-guard regardless of the news. Investing in stocks with volatile price swings can be a recipe for investments at risk of performing poorly.
  • Seeking Alpha’s quant ratings provides you with tools for evaluating stocks to create a portfolio to identify high-risk stocks and those with Strong Buy ratings.

Growth of sales or growth of market basket or consumer price index concept. CPI. Shopping basket on coin stacks. 3d illustration

Kwarkot/iStock via Getty Images

July CPI, Inflation, and the Jobs Report

Barring this week's CPI results which the markets perceived as good news that led to a rally with the Nasdaq +20% from recent lows and the S&P 500 reaching the highest level in three months, the markets have been on a volatile swing. Where bad news for the economy was good for the markets, potentially leading the Fed to ease monetary policy, good news for the economy appeared bad as it could prompt the Fed to increase rates.

Weeks of bear market bounce have seen little signs of cracking. Following the latest jobs report, investors were concerned about potential headwinds that 'sizzling' employment and labor strength would be an indication that the Fed would increase rates, or at the very least, proceed with a 75-basis point hike. And although the initial news of a strong labor market resulted in mixed results because investors still fear recession and a potential hawkish Fed, July's CPI of 8.5%, a decline from June's 9.1%, may be the turning point that good news is good news.

U.S. CPI Chart - Cooling Inflation

U.S. CPI Chart - Cooling Inflation (U.S. CPI Chart - Cooling Inflation (Bloomberg - Bureau of Labor Statistics))

As CPI measured softer than expected in July, inflation appears to be cooling, prompting stocks to soar yesterday. Inflation came in below expectations, which indicates to the market that the Fed may not have to continue raising rates aggressively. While they want to see more consistent downward pressure in core CPI, what's interesting is that most of the decrease resulted from a fall in energy - fuel, and gas.

Sticky CPI Chart

Sticky CPI Chart (Sticky CPI Chart (NewsWeek))

Whereas food and shelter costs experienced the biggest increases, these sticky costs may take a while to come down. Food increases have been the most sensitive, +10.9% from last year, the largest increase since 1979. Because these categories tend to be essential and therefore prices are difficult to control, recession fears remain, as the Fed may need to raise rates to temper rising costs. With this precaution in mind, the latest CPI report could spell big news for some stocks, especially those beaten-down throughout the year. Stocks like (UPST), (SPOT), (NASDAQ:ROKU), (SHOP), (DOCU), and (NYSE:CVNA) that our Quant Ratings & Factor Grades have warned investors to avoid or sell long before their earnings misses, may be rallying on irrational exuberance following Wednesday's CPI. Some investors are jumping headfirst into the action, not considering the potential consequences of stocks whose characteristics have historically been associated with poor future performance. While some growth stocks may benefit from the 'good news,' it's vital to take into account their underlying metrics.

Are Growth Stocks Back in Action?

Irrational exuberance may be prompting the latest market rally. Quality is key to selecting stocks, especially following positive news, which is why I emphasize fundamentals and focus on key characteristics like valuation, growth, momentum, profitability, and EPS revisions before selecting stocks for a portfolio. Although the latest CPI results were received as good news, the Fed has said they need to see more than one month of cooling before they make a final decision.

While CPI came in lower than expected, inflation is still high; food costs are high; housing costs keep climbing, which could result in the Fed raising rates. The jury is still out on that. And because many growth stocks are sensitive to interest rates, it's important to dig into what makes them attractive for investment.

When you discount future earnings with higher interest rates, it produces lower growth and less profitability from an expectation perspective. The notion that interest rates won't be as high as the Fed indicated bodes well for lower-quality stocks that now, when you discount future earnings, can use a lower discount rate. Take Carvana Co. (CVNA), for example.

Carvana (CVNA) Rallies following July CPI Report

Carvana (CVNA) Stock Rallies following July CPI Report

Carvana ((CVNA)) Stock Rallies following July CPI Report (Carvana ((CVNA)) Stock Rallies following July CPI Report (Seeking Alpha Premium))

The stock rallied +14.19% on the news of July CPI, despite CVNA's one-year share price decline of 87.22%. JPMorgan downgraded the stock following its recent 2022 Q2 Earnings miss that resulted in 16 analysts' downward revisions over 90 days. Just because CPI is better-than-anticipated does not mean the Fed will be dovish. A one-day rally may be the result of investors betting on a best worst-case scenario. Better CPI does not mean that valuations and earnings won't be hit as hard as anticipated. This rally and positive sentiment on the heels of the report may be leading to false rationale of stocks at risk of performing badly, according to quant ratings; a result of irrational exuberance; companies like Carvana are still unprofitable.

Roku, Inc.

Roku, Inc. is another example. Take a look at its poor investment characteristics below.

ROKU's Poor Report Card & Ratings on Key Investment Characteristics

Roku Stock Poor Report Card & Ratings on Key Investment Characteristics

Roku Stock Poor Report Card & Ratings on Key Investment Characteristics (Roku Stock Poor Report Card & Ratings on Key Investment Characteristics (Seeking Alpha Premium))

Not only is this stock at a high risk of performing poorly, but the stock also experienced a +3.82% boost to close the market, following CPI results, making positive pre-market moves to start the next day. Will improvement in market sentiment pose beneficial for stocks like UPST, SPOT, ROKU, SHOP, DOCU, and CVNA? Only time will tell. Seeking Alpha's Quant Grading System is an excellent resource that provides warnings when a stock is at risk of performing badly to allow investors to focus on quality stocks to grow their investment portfolio. Avoid the stock losers. Assess stocks based upon key characteristics.

Stock Valuation, EPS Revisions, and Momentum

As I recently wrote in Heed the Warnings: Earnings In the Red Could Mean Your Stock is Dead Money,

"Seeking Alpha's quantitative system aims to focus on the best characteristics of the fundamental building blocks of stocks. We like to base the quant investment strategy on highlighting companies with solid growth potential at a reasonable price, also known as Growth at a Reasonable Price (GARP). GARP measures the quality and health of stocks using our grading system. It also showcases those stocks with less-than-optimal characteristics. Let's dive into the first building block, valuation."

Stock Valuation

Investors want to know a stock's worth and whether it is priced at a premium or discounted. Using Upstart Holdings, Inc. (UPST) as the valuation, momentum, and revisions grade example, this cloud-based artificial intelligence (AI) lending platform is extremely unattractive on each of these characteristics, landing an overall F grade. Not only is UPST considered highly overpriced compared to its sector peers given its trailing P/E ratio of 35.20x is 221.15% higher than the sector, its forward Price/Book of 4.15x is also a 246.59% difference to the sector.

Upstart Stock Valuation

Upstart Stock Valuation (Upstart Stock Valuation (Seeking Alpha Premium))

Meanwhile, the Financials sector median is at 10.96x and 1.20x, respectively. And with its latest 2022 Q2 earnings miss that produced an EPS of $0.01 that missed by $0.07 and revenue of $228.16M that missed by nearly 18% year-over-year, eight analysts gave downward revisions in the last 90 days. There are many factors that may have contributed to the stock's disappointing revisions. The key is diving to uncover the reasons and how they play into the momentum and outlook of the company.

Upstart (UPST) Stock Momentum

Upstart ((UPST)) Stock Momentum (Upstart ((UPST)) Stock Momentum (Seeking Alpha Premium))

Despite market speculators cheering this stock following July's softer-than-expected inflation data, prompting Upstart's bullish upswing, along with several other stocks, when assessing UPST's quarterly momentum and YTD share price decline of 76.84%, investors may want to proceed with caution. We consider the Momentum Factor Grade one of the most important of our five core factors concerning price predictability, which is why Upstart's risk warning and its momentum grades are well warranted. All of the stocks mentioned here, UPST, SPOT, ROKU, SHOP, DOCU, and CVNA have been bearish and displayed weak guidance. Before jumping into bearish ideas as a result of softer-than-expected inflation data, consider the overall picture and that the good news may have prompted a brief stint of irrational exuberance.


Less aggressive interest rates appeal to the markets and investors. Whether or not the Fed will be hawkish or dovish for the September 21st gathering remains to be seen. Before taking action for fear of missing out (FOMO), consider evaluating your stock pick(s) by creating a Seeking Alpha portfolio, a tool that will help determine the losers in a portfolio that can save you from catastrophic losses.

SA Quant Sell Recommendations vs S&P 500

SA Quant Sell Recommendations vs S&P 500 (SA Quant Sell Recommendations vs S&P 500 (Seeking Alpha Premium))

If you had some of the stocks mentioned in this article, UPST, SPOT, ROKU, SHOP, DOCU, and CVNA, you would have received a warning banner, or at the very least noted the poor factor grades and characteristics. Seeking Alpha's sell recommendations are a powerful way to help avoid catastrophic losses. The good news of moderating inflation may appear to be an opportunity to buy at a lower price. But these growth stocks come with risks with extreme risks. Like we've seen with the bearish bounce this year, good news can be bad for stocks, while bad news may be good. The latest CPI results may be good news this go-around, but we implore you to consider the Quant System that can readily identify stocks at risk, as well as those with Strong Buy recommendations.

This article was written by

Steven Cress profile picture
Head of Quantitative Strategies at Seeking Alpha. Data analysis and interpretation have taken center stage in my career. For my purpose, the interpretation of data is the process of making sense of statistics that have been collected, analyzed, and scored. This skill-set has served as a solid foundation for me to identify trends and make transparent predictions in the course of money management. It has also allowed me to develop user-friendly web-based tools that furnish individuals with the indicators and signals to instantly interpret the strength or weakness of a company's value. Importantly, this expertise has helped me build Wall Street trading desks, launch international hedge funds, and construct a SaaS FinTech investment research company. Prior to my role at Seeking Alpha as the Head of Quantitative Strategies, I founded a Hedge fund and Asset Management company (Cress Capital Management), I was the Head of International Business Development at Northern Trust, and the majority of my career was at Morgan Stanley running a proprietary trading desk.

Analyst’s Disclosure: I/we have no stock, option or similar derivative position in any of the companies mentioned, and no plans to initiate any such positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Seeking Alpha's Disclosure: Past performance is no guarantee of future results. No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment is suitable for a particular investor. Any views or opinions expressed above may not reflect those of Seeking Alpha as a whole. Seeking Alpha is not a licensed securities dealer, broker or US investment adviser or investment bank. Our analysts are third party authors that include both professional investors and individual investors who may not be licensed or certified by any institute or regulatory body.

Recommended For You

Comments (31)

To ensure this doesn’t happen in the future, please enable Javascript and cookies in your browser.
Is this happening to you frequently? Please report it on our feedback forum.
If you have an ad-blocker enabled you may be blocked from proceeding. Please disable your ad-blocker and refresh.