RiverNorthPhotography
Listen here or on the go via Apple Podcasts and Spotify
Transcript
Today, we're taking a really close look at a company that's been, let's say, hard to pin down, GameStop (NYSE:GME). You think video games, maybe malls, but our sources, paraphrased and quoted here, from our news team, Seeking Alpha analysts and straight from GME's stock page, its Virtual Analyst Report, tell a story of pretty fundamental change happening.
So our mission for this deeper dive into GME is simple. Cut through the noise. Look at recent news, financial reports like the latest Q1 earnings, analyst views, and figure out what they tell us is really going on with GameStop right now.
And the core puzzle presented is, how does a company known for physical stores end up with billions in cash and making big plays in crypto? That's the million dollar - or rather a billion dollar - question.
GameStop, founded '96, based in Texas. Traditionally, a specialty retailer. Games, consoles, accessories, digital content too, and increasingly collectibles, apparel, toys, gadgets. The story you know. But our sources immediately highlight this dramatic shift that GameStop's undergone significant changes, moving away from just being about traditional retail.
They point to CEO Ryan Cohen as the driver. The new focus, based on this material, is using the company's huge cash reserves to maybe become a 'new age investment holding company.' A company using its money to invest in other things.
And the number one target mentioned. Cryptocurrencies and blockchain initiatives. It's explicit. They mentioned allocating cash to Bitcoin as a treasury reserve asset.
It clears a signal towards, financial diversification, as they put it. Which leads us straight to maybe the most eye-popping detail in these sources, the sheer amount of cash GameStop has now. They keep calling it a cash rich company. And the numbers are pretty staggering. The latest Q1 report shows $6.4B in cash.
That's a massive leap from just $1B the previous year, same quarter. A six-fold increase in cash in twelve months, and this huge cash position gives them significant flexibility for strategic investments. It's the engine for this whole potential pivot.
They have the cash. Let's talk about those strategic investments the source has mentioned, especially the crypto side. Well, the most concrete thing detailed is the Bitcoin (BTC-USD) purchase. GameStop purchased almost 5,000 Bitcoin, and the report adds they have not added to the Bitcoin treasury position since then.
Analysts seem to think this might link to other blockchain things. They mentioned DePIN. Decentralized physical infrastructure networks. Basically, using blockchain for real-world stuff. Analysts see this and the Bitcoin move as suggesting GameStop has adaptability and willingness to explore innovative financial strategies. They're not just sitting still.
And the potential upside. Analysts think this shift, especially the Bitcoin part, could lead to significant upside potential if Bitcoin's value increases. It's a clear bet on that asset appreciating.
So that's the story that cash and the crypto pivot tells. But it's also really clear that the original business, the retail side, hasn't just disappeared. It's still there, and it's facing issues.
GameStop continues to face challenges within its core retail business. And the evidence? Things like declining sales and a shrinking physical footprint. Store closures are mentioned, particularly in international markets, and specifically noted is the recent divestiture of Canada, selling off a whole country's operations.
That's significant contraction. The Q1 numbers paint that picture too for the core business. Revenue fell year over year, a big drop down. And it missed compared to what analysts were expecting for revenue. So sales are declining and faster than expected.
If you break down those sales, hardware and accessories dropped quite a bit as a percentage of sales. Software also down. But collectibles were way up as a share of sales. People are still buying Funko pops and shirts, even if game sales are weaker.
And another point the Q1 report makes, even with sales down, they seem to be getting more efficient. SG&A: selling, general, and administrative costs, basically running the business, decreased as a percentage of sales.
And the cost of sales also fell relative to revenue. So, getting more efficient with the sales they do have. Which brings us to this kind of confusing financial picture overall seen in Q1 because despite the revenue miss, despite the shrinking core business, GameStop made a profit in Q1.
And earnings per share. EPS beat analyst consensus, and the operating loss shrank dramatically, too. So the bottom-line looks much healthier even with lower top-line revenue.
The contradiction, I guess, seems to be reflected in that Seeking Alpha rating, which is at a hold. A hold rating suggests just that - a mixed picture, not a clear buy, not a clear sell. Let's dig into our Seeking Alpha factor grades.
Growth an A+. That EPS growth number, year over year, is massive, far surpassing the sector's negative growth rate.
Momentum? An A-, driven by the stock price performance, recently up 17% over three months while the sector declined. The analysis says this indicates bullish sentiment and strong investor confidence.
EPS revisions in the past three months, no downward revisions. So analysts are getting more optimistic about future earnings, but while EPS revisions are up, there were two downward revenue revisions. So optimism on profit, pessimism on sales, still mixed.
Now for the not so good grades, valuation gets a D. Challenging, primarily because the stock price seems really high relative to the company's actual financial results. The PE ratio, price to earnings, is significantly higher than the sector median, suggesting it's considerably overpriced based on earnings.
The conclusion here seems to be the stock's value is driven more by speculation, hope for the future, than current business fundamentals.
Profitability, D+. Net income margin is below the sector median, so they're less efficient at turning sales into profit than their peers. And their EBITDA margin is also called significantly lower, pointing to persistent profitability challenges within that core retail operation.
Amazing grades for growth and momentum, probably tied to that stock surge and the Q1 profit surprise, but really poor grades for valuation and fundamental profitability.
When you look at GameStop versus traditional competitors mentioned, like Amazon (AMZN), Best Buy (BBY), Walmart (WMT), its unique value, according to these sources, isn't really about being a better retailer anymore.
Our sources frame its unique value now as its brand recognition and a very substantial community of dedicated retail investors. That meme stock energy, basically.
And how it's trying to leverage that plus the cash to pivot into this potential investment holding entity focused on crypto and blockchain.
So loads of cash for investments. Leveraging that strong brand and community. The pivot to Bitcoin and exploring new initiatives shows they're adaptable, willing to try new things, and potential upside if Bitcoin takes off.
And the concerns: One, that core retail business is declining sales, stores closing. Two, the new investments, crypto and blockchain, are speculative and add execution risk. Like, can they actually pull this off? Especially since there's no clear turnaround plan for its retail operations, creating uncertainty.
Three, the valuation is seen as very high, driven by speculation, which poses a risk to investors if that sentiment changes.
Which leads us perfectly into the final section in our sources, the bulls versus the bears. What are the bears saying according to this? The bears look at the technical charts, see mixed signals. They hammer on the valuation. They see the core retail business in structural decline, meaning it's not just temporary, it's fundamentally broken in their view.
And the pivot. They see it as adding strategic risk, not solving the problems. They say there's no credible turnaround plan for retail. The core bear thesis is a collapsing core business and valuation built on hope. That makes it a compelling short in their eyes.
So what's the counterargument? What do the bulls say? The bulls focus heavily on the brand. They call it unique, valuable, unlike any other company. They argue this brand is a powerful, intangible asset that doesn't show up properly on a balance sheet, so the value isn't just in the numbers.
It's in the name and the following. The opportunity for the bulls is leveraging that unique asset combined with all that cash to make these new ventures succeed.
So, summing up just based on the sources we've looked at today, GameStop is this fascinating mix. Financially strong in terms of cash, exploring new speculative territory like crypto, and even showed a surprise profit last quarter. But that traditional retail business is undeniably shrinking.
Sales are down even if they're getting a bit more efficient, and analysts are really divided. The quantitative scores show great momentum and earnings growth, but terrible valuation and fundamental profitability metrics.
The whole story seems to hinge on whether this big cash fueled bet on crypto and maybe other things pays off enough to outweigh the decline of the old business.
And just to reiterate, everything we discussed, it's purely based on the information within our sources. This is the picture they paint of GameStop right now. Which leaves us with a pretty big question to think about as investors.
Based only on what's in these sources, the shrinking retail, the billions in cash, the crypto bets, the conflicting metrics, how much weight should be given to something like a strong brand and a loyal community versus traditional fundamentals like sales growth and profitability, especially when a company is making such a dramatic, almost existential pivot.
What do you think?
